Showing posts with label Libya war. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Libya war. Show all posts

6/07/2013

U.N. Nominee Pushed Obama into Libya War


Πηγή: WND
By Art Moore
June 6 2013

As Congress continues to probe the White House’s handling of the Islamic jihad attack that killed the U.S. ambassador in Benghazi, President Obama is asking the Senate to approve as his new U.N. ambassador one of the key figures who persuaded him to intervene in Libya.

Samantha Power, 42, drew attention in 2008 when she resigned as an Obama campaign adviser after calling rival candidate Sen. Hillary Clinton a “monster.” But after Obama took office, the activist known for her crusade against genocide and her role in formulating and advocating a policy that puts global humanitarian crises ahead of U.S. interests persuaded Obama to use military force in Libya in her role as the National Security Council special adviser on human rights.

Power’s political rise was forecast in a National Interest magazine profile of her two years ago that placed her among a “new elite” that believes American foreign policy “must be fundamentally transformed from an obsession with national interests into a broader agenda that seeks justice for women and minorities, and promotes democracy.”

The U.N. ambassador position became open when Obama earlier today announced his appointment of Susan Rice as his new national security adviser to replace Tom Donilon. Obama had Rice pegged as Hillary Clinton’s successor as secretary of state but was forced to settle for John Kerry when Republican senators pushed back. The critics cited Rice’s prominent role as purveyor of the White House’s now debunked insistence that the death of U.S. Ambassador Christopher Stevens and three other Americans in Benghazi was the tragic outcome of a protest against an anti-Muslim video that turned violent.

Born in Dublin, Ireland, Power was raised in the U.S. and graduated from Yale and Harvard Law School. She was a correspondent for Time magazine and later The New Yorker, covering crises in Kosovo, Rwanda and Sudan. Her 2002 book, “A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide,” won a Pulitzer Prize for its analysis of why the U.S. has failed to stop genocide worldwide.

She is married to the well-known Harvard Law professor Cass Sunstein, who served as head of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs during Obama’s first term. Sunstein has advocated redistributing America’s wealth to poorer nations to pay “justice”.

As a foreign policy aide to Obama in the 2008 campaign, Power thought she was speaking off the record to a Scottish newspaper when she called Hillary Clinton a “monster.”

“We f***ed up in Ohio,” she told The Scotsman newspaper. “In Ohio, they are obsessed and Hillary is going to town on it, because she knows Ohio’s the only place they can win.

“She is a monster, too – that is off the record – she is stooping to anything,” Power said.

‘Shaming’ into action

Reporter Jacob Heilbrunn foresaw Power’s political rise in a profile of her for the May/June 2011 issue of National Interest magazine.

Noting her reputation as an outspoken crusader against genocide, Heilbrunn said Power “has made it her life’s mission to shame American statesmen into action and to transform U.S. foreign policy.”

Heilbrunn called her “a testament to the collapse of the old foreign policy establishment and the rise of a fresh elite.”

“This elite is united by a shared belief that American foreign policy must be fundamentally transformed from an obsession with national interests into a broader agenda that seeks justice for women and minorities, and promotes democracy whenever and wherever it can – at the point of a cruise missile if necessary,” Heilbrunn wrote in 2011.

Heilbrunn said Power “may be the most influential journalist-turned-presidential-adviser since a young Walter Lippmann drafted the Fourteen Points for Woodrow Wilson, only to become a chastened realist after the Treaty of Versailles made a mockery of Wilsonianism and the internationalist dream.”

In a 2003 New Republic article, Power called for a complete “overhauling” of U.S. foreign policy to address crimes committed, sponsored, or permitted by the United States.”

“U.S. foreign policy has to be rethought,” she wrote. “It needs not tweaking but overhauling. We need: a historical reckoning with crimes committed, sponsored, or permitted by the United States. This would entail restoring FOIA to its pre- Bush stature, opening the files, and acknowledging the force of a mantra we have spent the last decade promoting in Guatemala, South Africa, and Yugoslavia: A country has to look back before it can move forward. Instituting a doctrine of the mea culpa would enhance our credibility by showing that American decision-makers do not endorse the sins of their predecessors.”

Power said U.S. foreign policy “should inject first-order concern for human rights into every policy decision. American decision-makers must understand how damaging a foreign policy that privileges order and profit over justice really is in the long term.”

In a 2002 interview, Power proposed imposing a peace deal on the Israelis and the Palestinians through military intervention but saw pro-Israel American Jews as an obstacle.

Military intervention “might mean alienating a domestic constituency of tremendous political and financial import,” she said laughing.

She called for shifting U.S. funding from the Israeli military to the building of a Palestinian state and equated then-Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s actions defending Israel from terrorist attacks with Yasser Arafat’s leadership of the Palestinians, asserting “both have been dreadfully irresponsible, and unfortunately it does require external intervention.”

Crafter of new doctrine

As WND reported, Power founded and headed a research center that had a seat on the committee that invented the “Responsibility to Protect” military doctrine used by Obama to justify U.S. and international airstrikes against Libya.

Responsibility to Protect, or Responsibility to Act, as cited by Obama, is based on the concept that sovereignty is a responsibility that can be revoked if a country is accused of “war crimes,” “genocide,” “crimes against humanity” or “ethnic cleansing.”

The term “war crimes” has at times been indiscriminately used by U.N.-backed international bodies, including the International Criminal Court, or ICC, which applied it to Israeli anti-terror operations in the Gaza Strip. Some critics fear the ICC could be used to prosecute U.S. troops.

WND was first to report billionaire philanthropist George Soros is a primary funder and key proponent of the Global Centre for Responsibility to Protect, the world’s leading organization pushing the military doctrine.

The committee that devised the Responsibility to Protect doctrine included Arab League Secretary General Amre Moussa and Palestinian legislator Hanan Ashrawi, a staunch denier of the Holocaust who long served as a deputy for Arafat.

4/12/2012

UK experts blame Nato for Libya refugee tragedy

Experts used forensic oceanography to trace the exact movements of the dinghy 

Πηγή: EUobserver
BY NIKOLAJ NIELSEN
April 12 2012

BRUSSELS - A detailed 90-page forensic report by Goldsmiths, the University of London released on Wednesday (11 April) says Nato contributed to the deaths of 63 refugees in one boat of 72 fleeing Libya by attempting to cross the Mediterranean last year.

The study also links a British military helicopter and a French warship to the tragedy.

Four of the nine survivors have testified that 18 hours into the journey a military helicopter hovered overhead.

Thinking they would be rescued, the captain - suspected of being a smuggler - threw his sat phone overboard. The small chopper returned a few hours later and dropped water and biscuits. Survivors said it had the word "Army" or possibly "Rescue Army" written across it and was either grey or green in colour.

Experts at Goldsmiths used forensic oceanography technology to trace the exact location and movements of the inflatable rubber dinghy.

They say the chopper described by the survivors was most likely a British Westland Lynx helicopter, known to operate in the area during the conflict. But Britain's defence ministry denies that any of its helicopters made contact with the boat.

The new report also says that a warship which came in contact with the dinghy was most likely French. Survivors said they could see people in military uniforms on the vessel looking at them through binoculars and taking photos.

"At first the ship was very far. Maybe 700 metres. They then circled around us, three times, until they came very close, 10 metres. We were watching them, and they were watching us. We are showing them the dead bodies. We drank water from the sea to show them we are thirsty. The people on boat took pictures, nothing else," said Dain Haile Gerbre, a survivor who was later granted asylum in Italy.

The dingy also came in contact with two fishing boats, who did nothing to help.

Despite being spotted by the various boats and helicopters, it washed back up on the Libyan shore some 160km east of Tripoli 14 days later.

Eleven people had survived, but one died while arriving on shore. Another person died later of exhaustion and from lack of proper medical treatment by Libyan authorities.

The boat left Libya sometime after midnight on 26 March 2011 and made distress call 18 hours into its journey. Their call for help was picked up by the Italian Coastguard and passed onto Nato Command Naples a few hours later.

Nato denies that any of its ships or military vessels were near the boat despite having declared the region a military zone under its control.

The Council of Europe (CoE), the Strasbourg-based human rights watchdog, in a separate report last month also said that two Nato warships were most likely in the boat's vicinity.

Despite requests, Nato has not released to the CoE the data that reveals the exact locations of its ships around the time of incident.

The Goldsmith report says some 38 naval assets were in operation in waters off the coast of Libya between 27 March and 10 April.

"Combing the analysis of synthetic aperture radar data, we were able to demonstrate that between the 28 and 29 March 2011 a large number of ships were located in the area, some of which were at distance of between 20 and 38 nautical miles to the migrant's boat," it said.



8/18/2011

NATO: "Mental Tests" and Civilian's Casualties




On a recent Unified Protector Press Conference Carmen Romero (NATO Deputy Spokesperson) along with Colonel Roland Lavoie (Spokesperson for the Operation Unified Protector) faced with a difficult and rather unexpected situation whith AP's journalist Slobodan LeKic posed.Slobo in a rather hesitant tone asked them:

"There's been recently criticism of NATO, especially at the United Nations and the UN Security Council members, that NATO has overstepped its mandate because of the fact that in this current situation where the pro-Qadhafi forces are obviously on the defensive, NATO is still striking... mounting air strikes against them, although they're only aiming their fire at the attacking forces, at the attacking rebel forces. They're not endangering or threatening civilians. And that's why several countries have expressed unease with this continuing attack, which they say is biased in the sense that it's helping the rebels and working against the forces which are on the defense. Can you comment on that?"

Colonel Roland Lavoie had just stated in his answer to the previews question that NATO as an organization has no mandate, apart from the mandate given by Resolutions 1970 and 73, "so basically we do the arms embargo, we enforce a No-Fly Zone. We do not... and we facilitate, of course, the arrival of the humanitarian aid. We do not train as NATO any of the belligerents".

Carmen Romero taking the lead stated that the mandate was approved "by all members..." and hastily refrased "by the United Nations Security Council". The fact is that the SC represent only the 7,77% of the 193 member states of the UN while the members that voted for it only the 5,12%. Furthermore she added that the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon praised NATO for its achievements in Libya. But if the role of NATO was to protect civilian's lives how was that Ban Ki-moon has recently voiced alarm over reports of civilians killed in Libya's civil war and called on all sides to do as much as possible to avoid killing innocent people? If that is the key point NATO must admit failure.

Lavoie went on stating that "...when we strike at a tank it's because we have an understanding that this does represent a threat to the local population...". "Every time we engage a target this is the mental test that is in our mind, like is it a target that presents a threat to the civilian population, and if the answer is yes we will engage this threat" he said. This of course neither explain the results of the recent bombing of Majer where 85 people, including 33 children, 32 women and 20 men were killed, nor the reactions of the head of the U.N. cultural and scientific agency UNESCO, Irina Bokova, who issued an unusually sharp rebuke of the alliance for its July 30 air strikes against Libyan state television, which she said killed several “media workers.”
Perhaps NATO failed the mental test once more...

If there are still any doubts you can have a look at some of the results of the above mentioned "mental test" here.





8/17/2011

Rape Reporting During War: Why the Numbers Don't Mean What You Think They Do



Πηγή: Foreign Affairs
By Amber Peterman, Dara Kay Cohen, Tia Palermo, and Amelia Hoover Green
August 1, 2011

Reports of sexual violence during the ongoing unrest in Libya have captured headlines across the world. Libyan leader Muammar al-Qaddafi's forces, some have alleged, were given Viagra to facilitate their rape of hundreds, if not thousands, of victims. Recently, Luis Moreno-Ocampo, the chief prosecutor at the International Criminal Court, and U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton both expressed outrage at what was apparently a purposeful campaign. Yet recent reports by the U.N. and by advocacy groups shed doubt on these claims. Amnesty International, for example, has been unable to locate a single rape victim, or even anyone who knows a victim.

As the veracity of stories about sexual violence in Libya came into question, the American Journal of Public Health published a study estimating that the prevalence of rape in the Democratic Republic of the Congo was far worse than previously documented. The article estimated that between 2006 and 2007 more than 400,000 women between the ages of 15 and 49 were raped during the war there -- 26 times the U.N.'s official count.

So what are we to make of these two cases -- a possible exaggeration of rape in Libya and a gross underestimation of it in the DRC? Wartime sexual violence has rightly been called a hidden epidemic; in truth, we know very little about its actual magnitude and impact. Reports of rape are increasingly common in countries wracked by conflict, such as Colombia, the DRC, East Timor, Côte d'Ivoire, Libya, and Sudan, but no one knows what the relationship is between increased reports and increased rape. Even in peacetime, sexual violence is severely and unevenly underreported. Beyond prevalence, patterns of where, when, and by whom rape is committed -- not to mention why it is committed -- are even less clear. War exponentially worsens these problems. As a result, estimates of rape in prominent conflicts are often unreliable.

The lack of clarity about wartime sexual violence is hardly surprising. Wartime rape is violent and brutal. Few of us want to think about it, talk about it, or read about it. Even when it does make headlines, it is the sensational details, not meaningful analysis of patterns and causes, that are often reported. And researchers are as apt as anyone to look away. The study of wartime rape has been marginalized as a "feminist" or "gender" issue. For many years, research on sexual violence was considered too unseemly a topic for top academic publications. Social scientists and statisticians rarely collect systematic data on wartime rape; instead, they frequently rely on victim narratives recorded by human rights advocates, aid workers, and journalists; as well as law enforcement reports; and hospital records.
A 2002 BBC article stated that "a girl born in South Africa will have a greater chance of being raped than learning how to read." It is almost certainly not true that the rape rate there surpasses 97.5 percent, the U.N. estimate for literacy among South African females aged 15 to 24.

8/16/2011

Libya: Escalating War to anticipate Palestine's State recognition?



It is logical that the war in Libya should come to an end till 20 September when the UAE will issue the full membership of Palestine into the UN. Otherwise this conflict will become a leverage for pressure as the Arab states that have till now backed the NATO's Unified Protector operation could step back, leak information to the media and so on. This means that in the next 30 days the hardest part of the dirty job of forcing democracy by killing civilians is going to take place intensified. 

This is the pick point of this war as the devisions among the rebels have been recently underlined by the murder of General Abdul Fatah Youni  resulting to the dissolution of their own cabinet. US would not like to let this bargaining chip to the hands of the Arabs in view of the crucial upcoming negotiations on the hottest post in the Middle East. But it remains a big question mark how many innocent civilian's lives will this rushing act of open regime change operation have to take in order to succeed. 

The mainstream media finally accepting the support to Qaddafi's regime report that negotiations are still on the table. While on 8 August the Navy scheduled to hold a commemorative ceremony aboard the guided missile destroyer USS Barry (DDG 52) for the 2,000th Tomahawk cruise missile combat launch on Aug. 5 at Naval Station Norfolk, Va. , missiles that cost between $US600,000 and $US1.2 million each, the same time that famine in Somalia has killed more than 29,000 kids in the last 90 days it is clear that the regime change is not a wishful thought for all Libyans. Furthermore it is a sarcastic u-turn the newly negotiations prospect now pushed by the media. It is not one person's war going on in Libya after all they admit. It is a cruel civil war almost impossible to have a happy end...


Oil deals on Libya's war started


Austria's OMV Q2 profit falls 25% on Libya's war

(On 28/3 Qatar cut an oil deal  with the Transitional National Council resaulting in that it became the first Arab State to recognize the TNC (by the next day). This action came before by the U.S. Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”) on 29/4 issued the permition (while US hadn't yet recognized the NTC) authorizing transactions related to certain oil, gas, or petroleum by US persons involving Qatar Petroleum and the Vitol group of companies exported from Libya under the auspices of the TNC. On 10/6 the fist shipment of oil arived to the US, namely 1.2 million barrels of Libyan crude oil. Next it was UAE's turn to pull the string.)

Πηγή: MENAFN
Aug 11 2011

OMV's chief executive, Gerhard Roiss, said that due to the political upheaval in Libya, the Austrian oil firm's profit dropped 25 percent in the second quarter to USD337,6 million ftom USD449 million in the same period in 2010, reported the National.
Roiss added that the company, which 20 percent of is owned by the Abu Dhabi government, started negotiations with the Libyan Transitional National Council in order to restart production in the country which contributed with 10 percent of the company's outpout in 2010.
He also said that the shutdown in Libya's operations forced the company to purchase replacement crude for its low-margin refining operations.
It is worth noting that the company's production was also affected by the unrest in Yemen, since an attqack on a pipeline in March stopped operations, however, the pipeline was fixed in July and oil pumping was resumed.

8/12/2011

Why Congress Must Stop Obama's Libyan Warmongering


August 9, 2011


Babies have short attention spans. Congressmen are even worse. A couple months ago legislators were outraged over the willingness of President Barack Obama to ignore the Constitution by going to war in Libya. Now the issue is all but forgotten.

The debt-limit fight offered Congress an excuse for being preoccupied. But now legislators again should confront the president’s law breaking. In recent years presidents have taken on kingly airs. Frustrated with only being tasked to fight wars approved by Congress, they now claim the unilateral authority to bomb, invade and occupy other nations. They make no distinction between defensive response and aggressive action. Like monarchs of old, today’s presidents attack any country they choose and fight as long as they wish.

This may be the dream of inveterate warmongers, but it is a nightmare for anyone who believes in limited, republican government. In many ways the Bush administration represented the apotheosis of this philosophy: President George W. Bush claimed the power to ignore express constitutional liberties for the (potentially unlimited) duration of a war (on terrorism) with a ubiquitous (including the homeland) battlefield. If the government wanted to arrest an American citizen in America and forever hold him incommunicado in prison, so be it.

President Obama has not made claims quite so brazen, but his behavior differs little from that of his predecessor. Indeed, when it comes to making war he has done George Bush one or even two better.

The Constitution is clear. Article 1, Sec. 8 (11) of the Constitution states that "Congress shall have the power ... to declare war." Declare does not mean to officially label a conflict started by the president. Rather, it means to start or initiate war.

The Founders made the president commander-in-chief of the military (not the country, as some people seem to think) to fight wars which Congress authorized. He also was expected to defend against sudden attack. But those who wrote the Constitution were very clear that the chief executive could not wander around the globe smiting nations hither and yon.

The reason? They had lived through the British monarchy, in which a succession of kings and queens launched a succession of unnecessary and even frivolous conflicts. As future Supreme Court Chief Justice John Jay delicately put it, dubious motives often led kings “to engage in wars not sanctified by justice or the voice and interests of his people.”

At the Constitutional Convention there was virtually no support for transferring the English system to the new nation. Hence Article 1, Section 8, which James Wilson explained shifted the power to start wars to Congress: “It will not be in the power of a single man, or a single body of men, to involve us in such distress; for the important power of declaring war is in the legislature at large.” Even the great friend of executive power, Alexander Hamilton, allowed that the president's war-making authority was "in substance much inferior” to that of the British monarch, whose power “extends to the declaring of war."

None of the recent arguments made on behalf of turning America’s chief executive into an elective king are persuasive: Other presidents have abused their control of the military and ignored the nation’s fundamental law; Some limited, peripheral military actions may constitute an act of war rather than going to war; Legislators prefer to duck their constitutional responsibility. All true, but none justify this president violating the Constitution today.

The War Powers Resolution adds another legal layer. Given the propensity of modern presidents to violate the law, in 1973 Congress sought to create a legal framework governing military action. The president had to report to Congress when he took undertook hostilities and receive congressional authority to continue after sixty days.

President Obama initially made a show of complying with the WPR. But as his time ran out he simply declared that the law did not apply. The United States was involved in “non-kinetic support” activities, he said, not hostilities—even though Washington had initiated aggressive war against a nation which had in no way threatened America, was intent on ousting that country’s legally recognized government, backed ongoing allied combat operations, and continued to use U.S. bombs, missiles, and drones to kill Libyan military personnel and destroy Libyan military materiel. Even the White House counsel disagreed with the president.

Barack Obama once grandly declared that “we will again set an example for the world that the law is not subject to the whims of stubborn rulers.” But now, akin to Alice in Wonderland, we find that words apparently only mean what the president says they mean.

To their credit, congressional Republicans and Democrats alike were angered by the dishonest presidential brush-off. The administration managed to hold off efforts to defund the war, but lost support for a policy increasingly notable for its misrepresentations and mismanagement. The opposing bipartisan coalition looked likely to keep growing.

And then nothing happened.

Congress has a history of just talking about tough issues of war and peace, so often fraught with political controversy. It is easier to do nothing. If the war turns out well, Congress gives a standing ovation when the president arrives for his State of the Union speech. If the war goes badly, members hold 535 press conferences denouncing him.

As University of Chicago Law School Professor Eric Posner put it: “It’s like you want someone to hold you back when you want to fight someone else. You want to look like you’re tough and you’re willing to fight, but you don’t really want to have to do it.”

The country cannot afford more legislative playacting.

First, the war threatens to draw the United States ever more deeply into an irrelevant conflict. While the administration made a show of turning responsibility over to NATO, it really is just Britain’s and France’s war. Only a third of the alliance members have provided any combat support, however minimal. Without substantial American participation NATO has been unable to do more than prevent the rebels from being defeated—prolonging the conflict and thus actually generating more civilian casualties.

Although the administration stepped back from active air operations, allied pressure caused it to maintain air and missile strikes and launch drone operations. In mid-July London requested more American support in surveillance, intelligence and aerial refueling. Moreover, there will be enormous pressure on Washington to join other NATO states in occupying and reconstructing a post-Qaddafi Libya (assuming there is a post-Qaddafi Libya).

Second, the war threatens to divert even more resources from meeting other needs. So far the war has been comparatively cheap, less than a billion dollars. However, that is another nearly billion dollars Uncle Sam does not have, money borrowed with the IOU tossed on top of the huge stack now towering over America’s future. Congress must cut programs big and small to restore federal finances to something vaguely responsible.

Third, the war threatens constitutional government. In the past, presidents have brazenly adopted dubious constitutional interpretations to justify executive war making. But past presidents have rarely made a claim so risible and transparently false as has President Obama. If he can get away with claiming that something is not what we all know it to be, then other presidents will be tempted to ignore other constitutional provisions by similarly denying the obvious.

Unfortunately, only Congress can constrain the president. A lawsuit, initiated by several legislators, is pending. But judges almost always avoid making decisions about what they call a “political question.” If the rule of law is to be vindicated, it will be on Capitol Hill.

Doing so will take courage—more than most legislators normally possess.

As Sen. Barack Obama observed in 2007: “No law can force a Congress to stand up to the president. . . . No law can give Congress a backbone if it refuses to stand up as the co-equal branch the Constitution made it.”

However, members take an oath to uphold the Constitution. They need to find their backbones.

It won’t be easy to stop the war, but legislators should continue pressing to end funding for ongoing military operations. Since no Americans are involved in combat, as the administration has told us, no Americans would be endangered by an immediate and complete fiscal cutoff. Other NATO governments might find themselves inconvenienced, but they should look elsewhere in the alliance for support. The United States remains involved in two wars, Afghanistan and Iraq, as well as two quasi-wars (involving regular drone strikes), Pakistan and Yemen. Other states should carry the full burden if they want this war.

Congress also should target near year’s appropriations, barring the use of Pentagon funds for operations against Libya. Equally important, legislators should directly target the Obama staff, zeroing out money to pay legal officials, such as the State Department’s Harold Koh, who helped develop the administration’s ludicrous argument. This step would punish the president for ignoring the Constitution and the law. It also might help deter future chief executives from law breaking.

Finally, the House should threaten impeachment. This might seem like an extreme step, but columnist Glenn Greenwald noted that “we’ve set a very low standard for our tolerance of rampant presidential law breaking.” That needs to change. Just filing an impeachment bill and holding hearings would embarrass the administration. Doing so might encourage President Obama and his successors to treat the Constitution with greater respect.

No president is above the law. Barack Obama is following in some not-so-illustrious footsteps as he conducts a war that is both foolish and illegal. Congress has a constitutional responsibility to force the president to comply with the law.

7/24/2011

The Role of the UN Security Council in Unleashing an Illegal War against Libya



Πηγή: Global Research
by Ronda Hauben
July 24, 2011


Journalists Question Security Council Support for Rebel Group

At the April 4 press conference marking the beginning of the Colombian Presidency of the Security Council for April, Nestor Osorio, the Colombian Ambassador to the United Nations was asked what on the surface would seem an unusual question by one of the journalists. The journalist said (1):

“In the wake of Security Council Resolution 1973 [authorizing military action against Libya–ed] are we to expect a more aggressive and proactive posture on the part of the Security Council in supporting rebel groups?”

The journalist gave several examples of such rebel groups as the IRA in the UK, ETA in Spain and perhaps the Corsican rebels in France. Another journalist added the example of the FARC in Colombia.

The question referred to the fact that with SC Resolution 1973, the UN Security Council had taken on to support an armed insurgency fighting against the government of a member nation of the UN.

The Colombian Ambassador responded that SC Resolution 1973 had not been adopted to support the rebels in Libya, but a rebel group which started out as civilians who had now become the core of the armed rebellion. The reason the Security Council had taken up the issue of Libya, he said, was because a member of the Security Council, Lebanon, had brought the issue to the Security Council. Ambassador Osorio added that the Arab League had asked for concrete action from the Security Council on Libya.

Is it, as Ambassador Osorio proposed, that the issue of Libya was taken up by the Security Council because Lebanon, a member of the Security Council, brought the issue to the attention of the other members? Is it that the Security Council was just deferring to the expertise of the Arab League, which the Colombian Ambassador presented as the relevant regional organization with respect to Libya?

The Colombian Ambassador’s remarks raise the question of how the Security Council made the decision to approve SC Resolution 1970 against Libya, the first of two resolutions on the issue. Was it as the Colombian Ambassador claimed because of a recommendation from the appropriate regional group, or was there a more complex process at work? Also, significantly in this situation, there were actually two conflicting recommendations to the Security Council from two groups, one from the Arab League, which is not a geographical regional group but is organized on some other basis, and the other from the geographic regional group that Libya is part of, from the African Union.

What were the factors that influenced the Security Council decisions first, to pass Security Council Resolution 1970 authorizing stringent sanctions, including a referral of Libyan officials to the International Criminal Court (ICC) and then, subsequently, to pass SC Resolution 1973, which authorized a no-fly zone and other military action? Ultimately these decisions set the basis for the NATO military alliance to join with the armed insurgency fighting against the government of Libya.

7/23/2011

Libya War Lies Worse Than Iraq



Πηγή: Froreign Policy Journal

by Thomas C. Mountain
July 23, 2011

The lies used to justify the NATO war against Libya have surpassed those created to justify the invasion of Iraq. Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch both had honest observers on the ground for months following the rebellion in eastern Libya and both have repudiated every major charge used to justify the NATO war on Libya.

According to the Amnesty observer, who is fluent in Arabic, there is not one confirmed instance of rape by the pro-Gadaffi fighters, not even a doctor who knew of one. All the Viagra mass rape stories were fabrications.

Amnesty could not verify a single “African mercenary” fighting for Gaddafi story, and the highly charged international satellite television accounts of African mercenaries raping women that were used to panic much of the eastern Libyan population into fleeing their homes were fabrications.

There were no confirmed accounts of helicopter gunships attacking civilians and no jet fighters bombing people, which completely invalidates any justification for the No-Fly Zone in the Security Council resolution used as an excuse for NATO to launch its attacks on Libya.

After three months on the ground in rebel controlled territory, the Amnesty investigator could only confirm 110 deaths in Benghazi, which included Gadaffi supporters.

Only 110 dead in Benghazi? Wait a minute, we were told thousands had died there, ten thousand even. No, only 110 lost their lives, including pro-government people.

No rapes, no African mercenaries, no helicopter gunships or bombers, and only 110 ten deaths prior to the launch of the NATO bombing campaign; every reason was based on a lie.

Today, according to the Libyan Red Crescent Society, over 1,100 civilians have been killed by NATO bombs, including over 400 women and children. Over 6,000 Libyan civilians have been injured or wounded by the bombing, many very seriously.

Compared to the war on Iraq, these numbers are tiny, but the reasons for the Libyan war have no merit in any form.

Saddam Hussein was evil; he invaded his neighbors in wars that killed up to a million. He used Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD) in the form of poison gas on both his neighbors and his own people, killing tens of thousands. He was brutal and corrupt and when American tanks rolled into Iraq the Iraqi people refused to fight for him, simply put their weapons down and went home.

Libya under Col. Gadaffi hasn’t invaded their neighbors. Gadaffi never used WMD on anyone, let alone his own people. As for Gadaffi being brutal, in Libya’s neighbor Algeria, the Algerian military fought a counterinsurgency for a decade in the 1990’s that witnessed the deaths of some 200,000 Algerians. Now that is brutal and nothing anywhere near this has happened in Libya.

In Egypt and Tunisia, western puppets like Mubarak and Ben Ali had almost no support amongst their people with few if anyone willing to fight and die to defend them.

The majority of the Libyan people are rallying behind the Libyan government and “the leader”, Muammar Gadaffi, with over one million people demonstrating in support on July 1 in Tripoli, the capital of Libya. Thousands of Libyan youth are on the front lines fighting the rebels and despite thousands of NATO air strikes, authentic journalists on the ground in western Libya report that their morale remains high.

In Egypt, the popular explosion that resulted in the Army seizing power from Mubarak began in the very poorest neighborhoods in Cairo and other Egyptian cities where the price of basic food items like bread, sugar, and cooking oil had skyrocketed and led to widespread hunger. In many parts of Egypt’s poor neighborhoods, gasoline/benzene is easier to find then clean drinking water. Medical care and education is only for those with the money to pay for it. Life for the people of Tunisia is not that much better.

In contrast, the Libyan people have the longest life expectancy in the Arab world. The Libyan people have the best, free public health system in the Arab world. The Libyan people have the best, free public education system in the Arab world. Most Libyan families own their own home and most Libyan families own their own automobile. Libya is so much better off than its neighbors every year tens of thousands of Egyptians and Tunisians migrated to Libya to earn money to feed their families, doing the dirty work the Libyan people refused to do.

When it comes to how Gadaffi oversaw a dramatic rise in the standard of living for the Libyan people despite decades of UN inSecurity Council sanctions against the Libyan economy, honest observers acknowledge that Gadaffi stands head and shoulders above the kings, sheiks, emirs and various dictators who rule the rest of the Arab world.

So why did NATO launch this war against Libya?

First of all, Gadaffi was on the verge of creating a new banking system in Africa that was going to put the IMF, World Bank, and assorted other western banksters out of business in Africa. No more predatory western loans used to cripple African economies; instead, a $42 billion dollar African Investment Bank would be supplying major loans at little or even zero interest rates.

Libya has funded major infrastructure projects across Africa that have begun to link up African economies and break the perpetual dependency on the western countries for imports. Here in Eritrea, the new road connecting Eritrea and Sudan is just one small example.

What seems to have finally tipped the balance in favor of direct western military intervention was the reported demand by Gadaffi that the USA oil companies who have long been major players in the Libyan petroleum industry were going to have to compensate Libya to the tune of tens of billions of dollars for the damage done to the Libyan economy by the USA instigated “Lockerbie Bombing” sanctions imposed by the UN inSecurity Council throughout the 1990’s into early 2000’s. This is based on the unearthing of evidence that the CIA paid millions of dollars to witnesses in the Lockerbie Bombing trial to change their stories to implicate Libya, which was used as the basis for the very damaging UN sanctions against Libya. The government of the USA lied and damaged Libya so the USA oil companies were going to have to pay up to cover the cost of their government’s actions. Not hard to see why Gadaffi had to go, is it?

Add the fact that Gadaffi had signaled clearly that he saw both Libya’s and Africa’s future economic development linked more to China and Russia, rather than the west, and it was just a matter of time before the CIA’s contingency plan to overthrow the Libyan government was put on the front burner.

NATO’s war against Libya has much more in common with NATO’s Kosovo war against Serbia. But one still cannot compare Gadaffi to Saddam or even the much smaller-time criminals in the Serbian leadership. The Libyan War lies are worse than Iraq.

7/19/2011

Libya: US officials hold meeting with Gaddafi regime

Col Muammar Gaddafi's regime has ben in talks with American envoys Photo: GETTY/EPA


Πηγή: The Telegraph
By Alex Spillius, Washington and Richard Spencer
11:35PM BST 18 Jul 2011

American envoys have met representatives of Col Muammar Gaddafi's regime, a move that will increase speculation that Nato is seeking a deal to end the four-month long conflict.
A United States official said the first acknowledged contact with the regime since the military campaign started was held "to deliver a clear and firm message that the only way to move forward is for Gaddafi to step down".

"This was not a negotiation. It was the delivery of a message. We have no plans to meet again, because the message has been delivered," she said.

The meeting brought together three senior US diplomats, including Jeffrey D. Feltman, the top State Department official in charge of Middle East policy, along with four members of Col Gaddafi's inner circle.

Reports from Libya said the meeting was held on Saturday in Tunisia, the day after the US and others agreed to recognise the rebel Transitional National Council as the country's legitimate rulers.

However, with the Libyan dictator clinging to power despite the near daily air raids by Nato forces, and public opinion about the conflict growing more sceptical, efforts to reach some sort of accommodation with Col Gaddafi have increased.

Alain Juppe, the French foreign minister, citing Libyan government emissaries, has said that Col Gaddafi was prepared to leave power by agreement.

"The Libyan regime is sending messengers everywhere, to Turkey, to New York, to Paris," he said.

Moussa Ibrahim, a spokesman for the Gaddafi regime, said the meeting was a "first step" towards repairing relations between the two countries.

"This is a first step and we want to take further steps. We don't want to be stuck in the past; we want to move forward all the time," he said.

The revelation came as Libyan rebels claimed the capture of Brega, though Gaddafi loyalists said they still held the key coastal city.

Rebels are holding eastern Libya and pockets in the west, but until Monday's assertion that Brega had been taken, had not made decisive moves towards the capital Tripoli, where Col Gaddafi remains entrenched.

After a weekend of vicious street-by-street combat, a rebel spokesman said they had surrounded or taken all parts of the town, except for an area where 150-200 loyalist troops were holding out.

Most regime forces had retreated to the next town along the coast, Ras Lanuf, he said.

It would be the regime's first significant defeat on the eastern front since late March.

The capture of Brega, home to Libya's biggest oil refinery and terminal complex, would be a major strategic and psychological victory for the Libyan opposition.

After the initial thrusts and counterthrusts of the campaign, in which Brega changed hands several times, the main wing of the rebel force has been unable to break west from its outpost in Ajdabiya, south-west of the headquarters in Benghazi.

With the lifting of the government's siege of Misurata and the rebels' slow advance in the south west, the regime is now unequivocally on the back foot for the first time since shortly after the coalition bombardment began in mid-March.

Britain, which has taken a tough line in arguing for more pressure on Col Gaddafi rather than negotiation, will hope that, combined with additional cash promised on Friday at a meeting of the Libya contact group in Istanbul, the military developments will see the regime start to crumble before a deal is reached.

Nato also continued its aerial attacks, destroying the civilian radar base at Tripoli airport, saying it was being used for military purposes.

Shamsiddin Abdulmolah, a rebel spokesman, told journalists that Brega had been mined, but that rebel forces were now pushing west along the coast road towards Ras Lanuf, another refinery town.

Around 15 rebel fighters were killed in the battle, according to reports on the ground. The government said 19 of its troops died in Nato air raids in support of rebel forces.

David Cameron said there was no option but for the embattled Libyan leader to go immediately.

Speaking during his visit to South Africa, he said that a "peaceful transition" was needed.

While his host, President Jacob Zuma, has attacked the coalition bombing campaign and reiterated calls for it to stop to allow negotiations, Mr Cameron said Col Gaddafi still could not be trusted.

"He has occasionally announced a ceasefire but all the time he announces it, he is shelling, maiming, murdering his own citizens. That's why there is a UN resolution," the Prime Minister said at a joint press conference in Pretoria.

7/08/2011

House Blocks Funds For Libya Rebels, Refuses To Defund War



Doug Mataconis · Friday, July 8, 2011

The House of Representatives voted to block funds going to Libyan rebels, but declined to take the full step of defunding U.S. military action there entirely

7/06/2011

US Senate drops Libya resolution to focus on national debt

US Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has pulled a resolution to authorize the US military conflict in Libya from the Senate schedule

The US Senate hastily dropped plans to vote Tuesday on a symbolic resolution authorising the US role in Libya amid a Republican insurrection to demand action instead on the national debt.

Πηγή: The Telegraph 10:54PM BST 05 Jul 2011


Harry Reid, the Democratic Senate Majority leader, said: "We've agreed, notwithstanding the broad support for the Libyan resolution, the most important thing for us to focus on this week is the budget."
His comments came after several angry speeches from Republicans who complained that Libya was the wrong measure at the wrong time and noted Mr Reid had cancelled an annual week-long recess to make progress in stalled debt talks.