Showing posts with label Standard and Poor's. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Standard and Poor's. Show all posts

2/05/2013

U.S. Accuses S.&P. of Fraud in Suit on Loan Bundles

The offices of Standard & Poor’s in New York.

Πηγή: Dealbook
By ANDREW ROSS SORKIN AND MARY WILLIAMS WALSH
Feb 3 2013

The Justice Department late Monday filed civil fraud charges against the nation’s largest credit-ratings agency, Standard & Poor’s, accusing the firm of inflating the ratings of mortgage investments and setting them up for a crash when the financial crisis struck.

The suit, filed in federal court in Los Angeles, is the first significant federal action against the ratings industry, which during the boom years reaped record profits as it bestowed gilt-edged ratings on complex bundles of home loans that quickly went sour. The high ratings made many investments appear safer than they actually were, and are now seen as having contributed to a crisis that brought the financial system and the broader economy to its knees.

More than a dozen state prosecutors are expected to join the federal suit, and the New York attorney general is preparing a separate action. The Securities and Exchange Commission has also been investigating possible wrongdoing at S.& P.

From September 2004 through October 2007, S.&P. “knowingly and with the intent to defraud, devised, participated in, and executed a scheme to defraud investors” in certain mortgage-related securities, according to the suit filed against the agency and its parent company, McGraw-Hill Companies. S.&P. also falsely represented that its ratings “were objective, independent, uninfluenced by any conflicts of interest,” the suit said.

S.& P., which was first contacted by federal enforcement officials three years ago, said in a statement earlier Monday in anticipation of the suit that it had acted in good faith when it issued the ratings.

“A D.O.J. lawsuit would be entirely without factual or legal merit,” it said, adding that its competitors had given exactly the same ratings to all the securities it believed to be in question.

Settlement talks between S.& P. and the Justice Department broke down in the last two weeks after prosecutors sought a penalty in excess of $1 billion and insisted that the company admit wrongdoing, several people with knowledge of the talks said. That amount would wipe out the profits of McGraw-Hill for an entire year. S.& P. had proposed a settlement of around $100 million, the people said.

S.& P. also sought a deal that would allow it to neither admit nor deny guilt; the government pressed for an admission of guilt to at least one count of fraud, said the people. S.& P. told prosecutors it could not admit guilt without exposing itself to liability in a multitude of civil cases.

It was unclear whether state and federal authorities were looking at the other two major ratings agencies, Moody’s Investors Service and Fitch.

A spokesman for Moody’s declined to comment. A spokesman for Fitch, Daniel J. Noonan, said the agency could not comment on an action that appeared to focus on Standard & Poor’s, but added, “we have no reason to believe Fitch is a target of any such action.”

The case against S.& P. is said to focus on about 30 collateralized debt obligations, or C.D.O.’s, an exotic type of security made up of bundles of mortgage bonds, which in turn were composed of individual home loans. The securities were created at the height of the housing boom. S.& P. was paid fees of about $13 million for rating them.

Prosecutors, according to the people briefed on the discussions, have uncovered troves of e-mails written by S.& P. employees, which the government considers damaging. The firm gave the government more than 20 million pages of e-mails as part of its investigation, the people with knowledge of the process said.

Since the financial crisis in 2008, the ratings agencies’ business practices have been widely criticized and questions have been raised as to whether independent analysis was corrupted by Wall Street’s push for profits.

A Senate investigation made public in 2010 found that S.& P. and Moody’s used inaccurate rating models from 2004 to 2007 that failed to predict how high-risk residential mortgages would perform; allowed competitive pressures to affect their ratings; and failed to reassess past ratings after improving their models in 2006.

The companies failed to assign adequate staff to examine new and exotic investments, and neglected to take mortgage fraud, lax underwriting and “unsustainable home price appreciation” into account in their models, the inquiry found.

“Rating agencies continue to create an even bigger monster — the C.D.O. market,” one S.& P. employee wrote in an internal e-mail in December 2006. “Let’s hope we are all wealthy and retired by the time this house of card falters.”

Another S.& P. employee wrote in an instant message the next April, according to the Senate report: “We rate every deal. It could be structured by cows and we would rate it.”

The three major ratings agencies are typically paid by the issuers of the securities they rate — in this case, the banks that had packaged the mortgage-backed securities and wanted to market them. The investors who would buy the securities were not involved in the process but depended on the rating agencies’ assessments.

Although the three agencies tend to track one another, each has its own statistical methods for assessing the likelihood of a bond default. That has led to speculation that S.& P. analysts knew their method yielded unrealistic ratings, but issued the ratings anyway.

In its statement on Monday, S.& P. said it had begun stress-testing the mortgage-backed securities it rated as early as 2005, trying to see how they would perform in a severe market downturn. S.& P. said it had also sent out early warning signals, downgrading hundreds of mortgage-backed securities, starting in 2006. Nor was it the only one to have underestimated the coming crisis, it said — even the Federal Reserve’s open market committee believed at the time that any problems within the housing sector could be contained.

The Justice Department, the company said, “would be wrong in contending that S.& P. ratings were motivated by commercial considerations and not issued in good faith.”

For many years, the ratings agencies have defended themselves successfully in civil litigation by saying their ratings were independent opinions, protected by the First Amendment, which guarantees the right to free speech. Developments in the wake of the financial crisis have raised questions about the agencies’ independence however. For example, one federal judge, Shira A. Scheindlin, ruled in 2009 that the First Amendment did not apply in a lawsuit over ratings issued by S.& P. and Moody’s, because the mortgage-backed securities at issue had not been offered to the public at large. Judge Scheindlin also agreed with the plaintiffs, who argued the ratings were not opinions, but misrepresentations, possibly the result of fraud or negligence.

The federal action will be the first time a credit-rating agency has been charged under a 1989 law intended to protect taxpayers from frauds involving federally insured financial institutions, which since the financial crisis has been used against a number of federally insured banks, including Wells Fargo, Bank of America and Citigroup.

The government is taking a novel approach in this instance by accusing S.& P. of defrauding a federally insured institution and therefore injuring the taxpayer.

The government is expected to cite the demise of Wescorp, a federally insured credit union in Los Angeles that went bankrupt after investing in mortgage securities rated by S.& P. Wescorp will be showcased as an example of the contended fraud, and as a way to bring the case in California, people with knowledge of the proceedings said. The suit was filed in Federal District Court fore the Central District of California.

By bringing a civil suit, as opposed to a criminal case, the Justice Department’s burden of proof will be less, perhaps lowering the bar for a successful prosecution.

8/08/2012

S&P cuts outlook on Greece's rating from stable to 'negative'


Πηγή: Todays Zaman
By AP
August 8 2012

Standard & Poor's Ratings Services on Tuesday lowered its outlook on Greece's long-term credit rating, saying that the financially troubled nation will likely need further aid from its international lenders amid a worsening economy and delays implementing harsh austerity measures.

The ratings firm downgraded Greece's long-term sovereign credit rating outlook to "negative" from "stable." Its rating remained at "CCC," well into "junk" status. Greece's economy is worsening, so it will likely need as much as 7 billion euros ($8.7 billion) in additional financing, or 3.7 percent of its gross domestic product, from the European Union and the International Monetary Fund, S&P said.

The move to lower the outlook reflects the possibility that S&P will downgrade Greece's rating if the nation fails to get additional funding from other eurozone countries and the IMF. The country has been relying on such loans since high interest rates pushed it out of bond markets in 2010. In return, it has imposed harsh austerity, slashing pensions and salaries, repeatedly hiking taxes and increasing the retirement age. The firm projects that Greece's gross domestic product will shrink by 10 or 11 percent over this year and next. The European Union and IMF have assumed GDP will slow only between 4 percent and 5 percent during that period.

Greece has received two bailouts totaling 240 billion euros from other eurozone governments and the International Monetary Fund after bond investors would no longer lend it money at affordable rates. In return for the money, Greece is supposed to cut its budget deficit and reform its economy. However, the economy has continued to contract and the new government of Prime Minister Antonis Samaras has said it wants more time to meet some of the conditions. Even so, S&P anticipates that Greece's government will find it difficult to make the additional cuts required to satisfy the conditions to get its next slate of funding from the EU and IMF. "We see the likelihood of shortfalls, owing to election-related delays in the implementation of budgetary consolidation measures for the current year, as well as the worsening trajectory of the Greek economy," S&P said. A cutoff of bailout money could lead to Greece defaulting on its remaining obligations and possibly leaving the euro currency.



1/14/2012

S&P downgrades ratings on France, Italy, Spain, Austria 1 notch; Germany keeps AAA rating


Πηγή: Washington Post
By AP
Jan 14 2012


PARIS — Ratings agency Standard & Poor’s has downgraded the government debt of France, Austria, Italy and Spain by one notch, but maintained Germany’s at the coveted ‘AAA’ level.

The cuts, which eliminated France and Austria’s triple-A status, deal a heavy blow to the currency union’s ability to fight off a worsening debt crisis. In total, S&P cut its ratings on nine eurozone countries.

Italy was lowered by two notches to BBB+ from A, and Spain fell to A from AA-. Portugal and Cyprus also dropped two notches. The agency also cut ratings on Malta, Slovakia and Slovenia.

The downgrades come as crucial talks on cutting Greece’s massive debt pile appeared close to collapse Friday.


12/06/2011

US agency issues ultimatum to triple-A euro countries


Πηγή: EUobserver
BY ANDREW RETTMAN
Dec 6 2011

BRUSSELS - US ratings agency Standard & Poor's (S&P) has warned it might lower the grade of all six triple-A eurozone countries if the upcoming EU summit does not deliver.

The Wall-Street-based firm said on Monday (5 December) that a bad summit would hit the ratings of 15 eurozone economies, excluding Cyprus and Greece which already have rock-bottom levels. Five of the top-rated countries - Austria, Finland, Germany, Luxembourg and the Netherlands - might be cut by one notch, while France might go down by two.

It lambasted the EU's handling of the crisis so far as "slow and reluctant ... defensive and piecemeal" with leaders indulging in "open and prolonged" disputes on reform.

It noted the summit must deliver "a greater pooling of fiscal resources and obligations as well as enhanced mutual budgetary oversight" in order to give the European Central Bank the confidence to buy a lot more weak bonds.

It added that leaders must put forward a growth programme to stave off recession next year. "A reform process based on a pillar of fiscal austerity alone risks becoming self-defeating ... eroding the revenue side of national budgets," it said.

The S&P bombshell came shortly after France and Germany agreed to change the EU Treaty to enforce fiscal discipline.

Berlin and Paris reacted to S&P with a communique saying they "reaffirm that the proposals they made jointly today will reinforce the governance of the euro area in order to foster stability, competitiveness and growth."

The ratings warning caused Asian markets to fall after an earlier rally, amid fears that if the triple-A countries go down, it would make it harder for the EU's bail-out fund, the EFSF, to borrow money, creating a downward spiral.

"The market is unstable and has been moving up and down like a seesaw. Investors buy stocks on good news after a plunge and are selling unless the news moves in the right direction," Naoteru Teraoka from the Tokyo-based Chuo Mitsui Asset Management told Bloomberg. "It is time for Germany and France to act," Phillip Swagel, an economics professor at the University of Maryland, said.

Other analysts suggested that S&P's shock statement is designed to boost its own reputation after a dismal few months, however.

In August it cut the United States' triple-A rating in a report based on an alleged $2 trillion maths error which prompted subpoenas on insider trading. In November, it announced it had cut France's rating, then said it had made a mistake. Earlier this month it also 'upgraded' Brazil to a rating which the country already had and cut a type of Ukrainian bond which does not exist.

"It does seem as though they are being particularly aggressive in terms of their ratings changes," Kathy Jones from the US-based firm Charles Schwab told the Wall Street Journal on S&P's euro warning.


11/30/2011

BOMBSHELL: S&P downgrades 37 global banks; US credit rating at risk again


Πηγή: The Coming Depression
Nov 29 2011

“Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services today said it reviewed its ratings on 37 of the largest financial institutions in the world by applying its new ratings criteria for banks, which were published on Nov. 9, 2011″.


Following Fitch Ratings decision to lower the US outlook from stable to negative, the S&P has thrown yet another bombshell after it informed in an official release post NY close that it had just downgraded 37 global banks. Goldman, BofA, Citigroup, Morgan Stanley, BNY Mellon were amongst the cuts based on a new reviewing critera it applied. Japanese and UK banks were either cut or the outlook lowered as well.

The US does not longer held AAA rating from the three agencies because on August S&P lowered the grade. US Treasuries continue to rally despite the downgrade. Recent change in the outlook by Fitch had relatively no effect on the Treasury market. “Both the action and the timing had been previously signaled by Fitch and there was no FX reaction,” said Chris Walter, from UBS Strategy. Fitch mentioned back in August that a failure of the bipartisan committee to reduce the deficit would likely lead to a negative rating.

Rating agencies are demanding the government to implement more measures to lower current fiscal deficit that is above $1 trillion on a year basis. The public debt is estimated to be around $15 trillion. The failure of Congress to make a bill that includes a credible deficit reduction plan could trigger another downgrade in US rating. According to Fitch, the use of the US Dollar as a reserve currency help the country keep its AAA rating. Source: (1) FX Street News

Global fiat currency is to blame for this mess

We hope you all understand that this whole financial services bailout episode is more accurately about further shifting the risk towards the public balance sheet and away from the once privately held. (but first they had to extract their bonuses and comp packages.)

It is the largest transfer of wealth in history! When they are bailed out once again, they will also be compensated for the mere acceptance of the bailout funds. That’s the way it worked last time and the way we’re headed again this time.

For years people have been sounding the alarm about both the size/amount of public/household debt but to no avail. We saw we were headed for the wall; as politicians crossed their fingers and hoped for the best.

Now we have the de-leveraging continued de-leveraging of small, private businesses and households and the advent of too big too jai

World debt is in the trillions, there isn’t enough energy or materials to ever generate the kind of growth that will require to repay that amount. It will NEVER be paid back.

Fractional reserve banking, interest, fiat currency have put us here. A growth economy based upon loaning money into existence and creating debt is inherently doomed to fail. You cannot have infinite growth on a finite plante. We’ve hit the wall, economic contraction for a generation is the order of the day, year, and decades.

Our best hope is aiming for a steady state economy and living within our fiscal and environmental limits.

The IMF / ECB / EU / Banks etc. are preparing for a Greek default on their debt and that’s why they want banks to get another MASSIVE “cash injection”. They don’t have the courage to come out and say it though – they want the taxpayer to backstop this.

On the US downgrade: S&P is nuts

S&P has no right to issue a downgrade because it blew it on the mortgage-backed paper. The fact that S&P did blow it during the mortgage fiasco, by continuing for years to rate junk bonds as AAA, shows just how serious the United States fiscal problems are. It covered up the problem with US government debt for years and now it can no longer do so and retain its credibility.

By the way, the Chinese rating agency Dagong already downgraded the US to A, down from AA, last November and is considering further downgrades. S&P is behind the curve and Fitch & Moody’s are like the monkeys with their hands over their ears and mouths.



References:

(1) FX Street News