Showing posts with label BIS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label BIS. Show all posts

7/22/2020

The Dark Past Of The Bank For International Settlements




July 20 2020
By Patrick Wood and Carl Teichrib

Although written by Patrick Wood in 2005, nothing has changed to the historical fact of the Bank for International Settlements. It has nefarious roots and is the tap-root of modern globalization.

Today, the BIS is getting headlines again because of its direction of central banks to go cashless. It is readily apparent that it has not lost its power and influence over the decades. For anyone wanting to understand how the world really works, this is a must-read paper. ⁃ TN Editor

Created at Bretton Woods in 1944, the World Bank has been dominated by international bankers, members of the Council on Foreign Relations and later by the Trilateral Commission. Corruption and self-interest run amok as public funds are converted into private hands by the billions.

Introduction


According to The World Bank, it is,

“a vital source of financial and technical assistance to developing countries around the world. We are not a bank in the common sense. We are made up of two unique development institutions owned by 184 member countries—the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) and the International Development Association (IDA). Each institution plays a different but supportive role in our mission of global poverty reduction and the improvement of living standards. The IBRD focuses on middle income and creditworthy poor countries, while IDA focuses on the poorest countries in the world. Together we provide low-interest loans, interest-free credit and grants to developing countries for education, health, infrastructure, communications and many other purposes.” 1

High-minded words like “our mission of global poverty reduction and the improvement of living standards” would lead the reader to believe that the World Bank is some benevolent and global welfare organization. Why is it then, that The World Bank joins the International Monetary Fund and the World Trade Organization as organizations that people around the world just love to hate?

In reality, the World Bank carries its weight, along with the International Monetary Fund and the Bank for International Settlements, to forcibly integrate minor countries of the world into its own brand of capitalistic democracy.
World Bank Beginnings

A sibling of the IMF, the World Bank was born out of the U.N. Monetary and Financial Conference at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire in July, 1944. The original name given to the World Bank was the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) and reflects its original mission: to rebuild Europe after the devastation of World War II. The name “World Bank” was not actually adopted until 1975.

Both the IBRD and the IMF were created as independent specialized agencies of the United Nations, of which they remain to this day.

The word “Development” in the IBRD name was rather insignificant at the time because most of the southern hemisphere was still under colonial rule, with each colonial master responsible for the business activities in their respective countries.

Note: It is argued by some that there was an original desire by banking elites to put an end to colonialism by restructuring investment and trade patterns in colonized countries. This paper will not deal with this issue, but it should be noted that this has been exactly what has happened, in many cases being aided by the operations of the World Bank and the IMF.

As a “reconstruction” bank, however, the World Bank was impotent. It ultimately loaned only $497(US) million for reconstruction projects. The Marshall Plan, by contrast, became the true engine of the reconstruction of Europe by loaning over $41(US) billion by 1953.

The primary architects of the World Bank were Harry Dexter White and John Maynard Keynes, both of whom are summarized Global Banking: The International Monetary Fund (see article for complete details) as follows:

“Such is the moral fiber and intellectual credentials of the creators of the IMF [and the World Bank]: One was an English ideologue economist with a markedly global bent, and the other a corrupt and high-ranking U.S. government official who was a top Soviet spy.”2
Structure of the World Bank

Today, the World Bank consists of two primary units: The already-mentioned IBRD and the International Development Association (IDA), which was created in 1960.

The IBRD lends only to governments who are credit-worthy; in other words, there is an expectation that they will repay their loans. The IDA, by contrast, only lends to governments who are not credit-worthy and are usually the poorest nations. Together, they create a “one-two” punch in global lending to any government that they are able to talk into borrowing. The U.S. currently contributes about $1 billion per year of taxpayer funds to the IDA.

Three other affiliates combine with the World Bank, to be collectively called the World Bank Group:
The International Finance Corporation (IFC) – Founded in 1956, lends directly to the private sector in developing counties.

The Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA) -Founded in 1988, provides guarantees to investors in developing countries against losses caused by noncommercial risks.

The International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) – Founded in 1966, provides international facilities for conciliation and arbitration of investment disputes.

Headquarters for the World Bank is Washington, DC. It employs approximately 7,000 in the Washington complex, and another 3,000 in 109 offices scattered throughout member countries.

IBRD funds its lending operations by selling AAA-rated bonds and other debt instruments to other banks, pension funds, insurance companies and corporations around the world. By contrast, the IDA is funded by (taxpayer) contributions from member countries. Annual levels of lending is roughly equal between IBRD and IDA. While the IFC generates its own capital in open markets, MIGA and ICSID receive the majority of their funding from the World Bank, much of which is taxpayer funded.

Ownership of the World Bank consists of voting shares held by member countries, according to size and contributions. Currently, the U.S. is the largest shareholder with 16.4 percent of total votes. The next largest voting blocks are Japan (7.9 percent) and Germany (4.5 percent). Because major decisions require an 85 percent super-majority vote, the U.S. can effectively veto any change (100% -16.4% = 83.6%).

American Hegemony


It should be noted that the United Nations is headquartered in the United States, on land originally donated to it by David Rockefeller. The Bretton Woods Conference was held in New Hampshire. Every president of the World Bank has hailed from the United States. It is no wonder that the rest of the world views the World Bank as an American operation.

There has been an unwritten but traditional rule that the World Bank president will always be an American, while the president of the IMF is European. (A recent exception to this is the current IMF president, who is Canadian)

It is instructive to review the past presidents of the World Bank, because it demonstrates which elite cabal is really in control of World Bank operations. In turn, this will point strongly to the real beneficiaries of the World Bank hegemony. The complete biographies and accomplishments of these men far exceed the available space in this report, so only a few highlights are noted.

1. Eugene Meyer. June to December, 1946. Chairman, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve from 1930-1933; owner of the Washington Post; Member, Council on Foreign Relations; agent of Lazard Freres, Brown Brothers, Harriman; appointed head of the War Finance Corporation during WWI by Woodrow Wilson.

2. John J. McCloy. March 1947 to April 1949. Member and chair of the Council on Foreign Relations; Chairman, Ford Foundation; Chairman, Chase Manhattan Bank; lawyer whose firm was council to Chase Manhattan Bank.

3. Eugene Black. July 1949 to December 1962. Chairman, Board of Directors for the Federal Reserve System (1933-34); senior vice president of Chase Manhattan Bank; Member, Council on Foreign Relations; member of Bilderbergers; created the International Finance Corporation and the International Development Association at the World Bank.

4. George Woods. January 1963 to March 1968. Vice president of Harris, Forbes & Co.; vice president of Chase Bank; vice president of and board member of First Boston Corp. (one of the largest U.S. investment banking firms).

5. Robert Strange McNamara. April 1968 to June 1981. President and director of Ford Motor Company; Secretary of Defense in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations; member of Trilateral Commission, Council on Foreign Relations and Bilderbergers; honorary council trustee of Aspen Institute. Personally negotiated China’s entrance into the World Bank.

6. A.W. Clausen. July 1981 to June 1986. President, CEO and chairman of Bank of America; member, Trilateral Commission; member, Bretton-Woods Committee.

7. Barber B. Conable. July 1986 to August 1991. Member of U.S. House of Representatives from 1965 to 1985; member Trilateral Commission and Council on Foreign Relations; senior fellow, American Enterprise Institute; board member, New York Stock Exchange; member, Commission on Global Governance.

8. Lewis T. Preston. September 1991 to May 1995. President, CEO and chairman of J.P. Morgan & Co., and chairman of the executive committee; vice president of Morgan Guaranty Trust Co.; member and treasurer of Council on Foreign Relations; director of General Electric.

9. James D. Wolfensohn. June 1995 to 2005 Executive partner and head of the investment banking department, Salomon Brothers (New York); executive deputy chairman and managing director, Schroders Ltd. (London); director, Rockefeller Foundation; board member, Rockefeller University; honorary trustee, Brookings Institution; Director, Population Council (founded by John D. Rockefeller); member, Council on Foreign Relations.

10. Paul Wolfowitz. 2005 – present. Deputy Secretary of Defense (2001-2005); member, Trilateral Commission; member, Council on Foreign Relations; member, Bilderbergers; director of the neocon flagship, Project for the New American Century ( PNAC); member of the elite “Vulcans” group that advised George W. Bush on foreign policy during the 2000 presidential elections (other neocon members included Condoleezza Rice, Colin Powell and Richard Perle); member of and frequent speaker at Social Democrats USA (successor to the Socialist Party of America).

An important pattern emerges here. These men frame a 50-year time period stretching from 1946 to 2006. The early players have long since passed away. There was no social connection between the early and latter presidents. Yet, seven out of ten are members of the Council on Foreign Relations; four are members of the Trilateral Commission, seven have major global bank affiliations (Chase Manhattan, J.P. Morgan, Bank of America, First Boston, Brown Brothers, Harriman, Salomon Brothers, Federal Reserve), and four men were directly connected to Rockefeller interests.

A detailed analysis is not required to see the pattern emerge: Global bankers (the same old crowd) and their related global proxies, have completely dominated the World Bank for its entire history. Collectively and individually, they have always operated purposefully and consistently for their own self-interested, financial gain. Why would anyone expect even one of them to act out of character (e.g., be concerned for world poverty) while directing the helm of the World Bank?
Purposes of convenience

Whatever the true purposes of the World Bank and IMF might have been, the publicly displayed purposes have changed when it was convenient and necessary.

In 1944, reconstruction of war torn countries after WW II was the important issue.

When the Bank demonstrated its impotence by loaning only a pittance of less than $500 million, it changed its pubic image by positioning itself as a check and balance to the expansion of communism. Without the World Bank to engage all of the lesser countries of the world who were susceptible to communist influence, communism might spread and ultimately threaten to end the cold war with an ugly nuclear Holocaust.

Public and legislative sentiment ultimately fizzled and the Bank was again under heavy criticism when Robert Strange McNamara was appointed president.

Poverty Reduction: Trojan Horse


As noted above, McNamara was president of the World Bank from 1968 through 1981. He was also among the original membership of the Trilateral Commission, founded in 1973 by Rockefeller and Brzezinski, and was widely considered to be a central figure in the global elite of his day.

It was McNamara who caused the focus of the World Bank to fall on poverty and poverty reduction. This has essentially remained the siren call right into the present. This was a brilliant maneuver because who would ever say they are anti-poor or pro-poverty? Any attack on the Bank would thus be viewed as an attack on poverty relief itself. From 1968 onward, the battle cry of the Bank has been “eliminate poverty.”

This is clearly seen on the About Us page of the World Bank web site, where these words are prominently displayed:

“Each institution (IBRD and IDA) plays a different but supportive role in our mission of global poverty reduction and the improvement of living standards.“ [emphasis added]

However, Article I of The Articles of Agreement of the IBRD, as amended on February 16, 1989, state its official Purposes as follows:

(i) To assist in the reconstruction and development of territories of members by facilitating the investment of capital for productive purposes, including the restoration of economies destroyed or disrupted by war, the reconversion of productive facilities to peacetime needs and the encouragement of the development of productive facilities and resources in less developed countries.

(ii) To promote private foreign investment by means of guarantees or participations in loans and other investments made by private investors; and when private capital is not available on reasonable terms, to supplement private investment by providing, on suitable conditions, finance for productive purposes out of its own capital, funds raised by it and its other resources.

(iii) To promote the long-range balanced growth of international trade and the maintenance of equilibrium in balances of payments by encouraging international investment for the development of the productive resources of members, thereby assisting in raising productivity, the standard of living and conditions of labor in their territories.

(iv) To arrange the loans made or guaranteed by it in relation to international loans through other channels so that the more useful and urgent projects, large and small alike, will be dealt with first.

(v) To conduct its operations with due regard to the effect of international investment on business conditions in the territories of members and, in the immediate postwar years, to assist in bringing about a smooth transition from a wartime to a peacetime economy.

The Bank shall be guided in all its decisions by the purposes set forth above.3

Note that the word “poverty” does not appear even once. The reason is clear: Whatever “business as usual” might be with the Bank, it has nothing to do with poverty or poverty reduction. Rather, the Bank is in business to loan money by stimulating borrowing demand in developing countries, with a view to increasing international trade. The primary beneficiaries of international trade are the global corporations, and the poor are actually poorer as a result.

This hypocrisy was noted even by Nobel laureate and former World Bank chief economist, Joseph Stiglitz, as late as 2002:

As far as these ‘client countries’ were concerned, it was a charade in which the politicians pretended to do something to redress the problems [of poverty] while financial interests worked to preserve as much of the status quo as they could.4

Liberalization and Structural Adjustments


When Alden Clausen (also an original member of the Trilateral Commission) took over the reins from Robert McNamara in 1981, a massive shakeup in the bank occurred. As Stiglitz noted,

“In the early 1980’s a purge occurred inside the World Bank, in its research department, which guided the Bank’s thinking and direction.”5

Clausen, a true core member of the global elite, brought in a new chief economist with radical new ideas:

“…Ann Krueger, an international trade specialist, best known for her work on ‘rent seeking’ — how special interests use tariffs and other protectionist measures to increase their incomes at the expense of others…Krueger saw government as the problem. Free markets were the solution to the problems of developing countries.“6 [emphasis added]

This was precisely the time when so-called liberalization policies and Structural Adjustments were forcefully implemented as a means of forcing countries to privatize industries. If governments were the problem, then they should turn over areas of critical infrastructure to private multinational corporations which, according to Krueger, could perform better and more efficiently than bureaucratic government bodies.

Not surprisingly, most of the career staff economists left the Bank in the early 1980’s in protest over Clausen and Krueger’s policies.
How the Money Laundry Works

The mechanism and operation of Structural Adjustments, along with the tight cooperation between the IMF and the World Bank, was adequately covered in The August Review’s Global Banking: The International Monetary Fund. The following well-documented example will be the “picture worth a thousand words” in the Review’s effort to profile self-serving Bank and global corporate policies. It also demonstrates the “tag-team” approach used by the Bank and IMF in the prying open of closed markets in uncooperative countries. It’s a rather tangled story, but careful reading will produce understanding of how the “system” works.

Water Wars


In 1998, the IMF approved a loan of $138 million for Bolivia it described as designed to help the country control inflation and stabilize its domestic economy. The loan was contingent upon Bolivia’s adoption of a series of “structural reforms,” including Privatization of “all remaining public enterprises,” including water services. Once these loans were approved, Bolivia was under intense pressure from the World Bank to ensure that no public subsidies for water existed and that all water projects would be run on a “cost recovery” basis, meaning that citizens must pay the full construction, financing, operation and maintenance costs of a water project. Because water is an essential human need and is crucial for agriculture, cost recovery pricing is unusual, even in the developed world.

In this context, Cochabamba, the third largest city in Bolivia, put its water works up for sale in late 1999.

Only one entity, a consortium led by Bechtel subsidiary Aguas del Tunari, offered a bid, and it was awarded a 40-year concession to provide water. The exact details of the negotiation were kept secret, and Bechtel claimed that the numbers within the contract are “intellectual property.” But, it later came to light that the price included the financing by Cochabamba’s citizens of a part of a huge dam construction project being undertaken by Bechtel, even though water from the Misicuni Dam Project would be 600% more expensive than alternative water sources. Cochabambans were also required to pay Bechtel a contractually guaranteed 15% profit, meaning that the people of Cochabamba were asked to pay for investments while the private sector got the profits.

Immediately upon receiving the concession, the company raised water rates by as much as 400% in some instances. These increases came in an area where the minimum wage is less than $100 a month. After the price hike, self-employed men and women were estimated to pay one quarter of their monthly earnings for water.

The city’s residents were outraged. In January of 2000, a broad coalition called the Coordination for the Defense of Water and Life, or simply La Coordinadora, led by a local worker, Oscar Olivera, called for peaceful demonstrations. Cochabamba was shut down for four days by a general strike and transportation stoppage, but the demonstrations stopped once the government promised to intervene to lower water rates. However, when there were no results in February, the demonstrations started again. This time, however, demonstrators were met with tear gas and police opposition, leaving 175 injured and two youths blinded.

The threat that privatization of public services under GATS (General Agreement on Trade in Services) poses to democracy were demonstrated in March 2000. La Coordinadora held an unofficial referendum, counted nearly 50,000 votes, and announced that 96% of the respondents favored the cancellation of the contract with Aguas del Tunari. They were told by the water company that there was nothing to negotiate.

On April 4, the residents of the city returned to the streets, shutting down the city. Again, they were met with police resistance, and on April 8, the government declared martial law. The Bolivian military shot a 17-year-old protester in the face, killing him. However, the protests continued, and, on April 10, the government relented, signing an accord that agreed to the demand of the protesters to reverse the water concession. The people of Cochabamba took back their water.

Unfortunately, this inspiring story didn’t simply end with the victory for the people of Cochabamba. On February 25, 2002, Bechtel filed a grievance using investor protections granted in a Bolivia-Netherlands Bilateral Investment Agreement at the World Bank, demanding a $25 million dollar payment as compensation for lost profits.7

Note: Bechtel Engineering is the largest civil engineering company in the world. It is privately owned by the Bechtel family. For many years, general counsel (and vice-president) for Bechtel was none other than original Trilateral Commission member Caspar Weinberger.

Since then, the World Bank has granted additional “poverty reduction” loans to Bolivia. Carefully read the Bank’s current (2006) assessment on Bolivia found on its web site:

“Bolivia is experiencing a time of difficulty and uncertainty. In recent months, various political and social disturbances have escalated with serious consequences, culminating in the resignation of President Gonzalo Sánchez de Lozada in October 2003, and the appointment of Vice-President Carlos Mesa as President. The current administration inherits a difficult economic, political and social climate, which is compounded by long-term issues, such as profound inequality, an economy that has been adversely affected by the region’s recent economic slump, and widespread public disenchantment with corruption.”8

Political and social disturbances? Difficult economic, political and social climate? Profound inequality? Widespread disenchantment with corruption? It leaves one speechless.

So, in the case of Bolivia, we see the following in operation:

An IMF loan is made to Bolivia, with conditionalities

The World Bank steps in to enforce the conditionalities and impose structural adjustments

The World Bank loans “development” funds to Bolivia, and simultaneously brings in private bank consortiums to fund the various projects that Bechtel had in mind.

Bechtel makes a sole-source bid, and it is accepted.

The water project ends in total failure and Bechtel gets kicked out after extreme political pressure from consumers.

Bechtel files a “lost profit” claim according to a pre-negotiated “insurance guarantee” with the World Bank Group (MIGA, see above.)

If Bechtel wins its claim, it will be paid off with taxpayer money contributed by member countries.

Undoubtedly, any loans from private-sector banks that later turn sour, will be bailed-out with taxpayer funds as well.

This kind of operation is brazen stealing (albeit perhaps legally) of funds from everyone in sight: Bolivia, the city of Cochabamba, the people of Cochabamba, U.S. taxpayers. The only beneficiaries are Bechtel, the commercial banks and a few corrupt politicians who got their customary bribes and kickbacks.

A penetrating question remains to be answered: When did Bechtel first set their sights on the Bolivia deal? Did Bechtel have a role in suggesting or creating the conditionalities and Structural Adjustments specified by the World Bank in the first place? If so, there would be grounds for criminal investigation.

It is not likely that the World Bank will tell us, because of its very secretive inner workings. Even Stiglitz has noted,

“The IMF and World Bank still have disclosure standards far weaker than those of governments in democracies like the United States, or Sweden or Canada. They attempt to hide critical reports; it is only their inability to prevent leaks that often forces the eventual disclosure.”9
Corruption

The World Bank has received accusations of corruption for many years. Since the Bank is an independent specialized agency of the United Nations and considering the old adage, “The fruit doesn’t fall far from the tree”, this might not come as a surprise to most. The United Nations has a major and documented track record on corruption of every conceivable sort. It would be too simplistic to just leave it at that.

In May, 2004, Sen. Richard Lugar (R-Indiana), as Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, kicked off the most recent inquiry into corruption related to the activities of the multilateral development banks, of which the World Bank is foremost.

The heads of the various development banks were invited to testify (voluntarily) before the Committee. According to Sen. Lugar, James Wolfensohn “declined the invitation, citing the established practice of Bank officials not to testify before the legislatures of their numerous member countries.”

Witnesses before the Committee testified that as much as $100 billion may have been lost to corruption in World Bank lending projects.

In Sen. Lugar’s opening remarks, he points out that the entire history of the World Bank is suspect, with between 5 percent and 25 percent of all lending being lost to corruption.

“But corruption remains a serious problem. Dr. Jeffrey Winters of Northwestern University, who will testify before us today, estimates that the World Bank ‘has participated mostly passively in the corruption of roughly $100 billion of its loan funds intended for development.’ Other experts estimate that between 5 percent and 25 percent of the $525 billion that the World Bank has lent since 1946 has been misused. This is equivalent to between $26 billion and $130 billion. Even if corruption is at the low end of estimates, millions of people living in poverty may have lost opportunities to improve their health, education, and economic condition.”10

One must wonder why World Bank officials have been so sloppy and careless with taxpayer dollars. Even further, one must wonder if the corruption was a necessity to achieve the underlying purposes of the Bank, that is, to create bogus and unwanted projects in order to “stimulate” trade.

Sen. Lugar continued his opening remarks,

“Corruption thwarts development efforts in many ways. Bribes can influence important bank decisions on projects and on contractors. Misuse of funds can inflate project costs, deny needed assistance to the poor, and cause projects to fail. Stolen money may prop up dictatorships and finance human rights abuses. Moreover, when developing countries lose development bank funds through corruption, the taxpayers in those poor countries are still obligated to repay the development banks. So, not only are the impoverished cheated out of development benefits, they are left to repay the resulting debts to the banks.”11

It has not been determined which Bank employees might have taken bribes in exchange for influence, but one can be sure that any deal starting with corruption only has one direction to go — down. In the end, it is helpless individuals who are left holding the bag. The incurred debts and failed projects just add to the impoverishment of already poor people.

This is not to say that charges of corruption at the World Bank are modern revelations only. In 1994, marking the 50th anniversary of its creation at Bretton Woods, South End Press released “50 Years is Enough: The Case Against the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund,.” edited by Kevin Danaher. The book details official Bank and IMF reports that reveal the same kind of corruption back then. In addition, it revealed different types of corruption, for instance,

“Beyond the wasted money and the environmental devastation, there was an even more sinister side to the Bank during the McNamara years: the World Bank’s predilection for increasing support to military regimes that tortured and murdered their subjects, sometimes immediately after the violent overthrow of more democratic governments. In 1979, Senator James Abourezk (D-South Dakota) denounced the bank on the Senate floor, noting that the Bank was increasing ‘loans to four newly repressive governments [Chile, Uruguay, Argentina and the Philippines] twice as fast as all others.’ He noted that 15 of the world’s most repressive governments would receive a third of all World Bank loan commitments in 1979, and that Congress and the Carter administration had cut off bilateral aid to four of the 15 — Argentina, Chile, Uruguay and Ethiopia — for flagrant human rights violations. He blasted the Bank’s ‘excessive secretiveness’ and reminded his colleagues that ‘we vote the money, yet we do not know where it goes.'” 12

The text speaks for itself and needs no comment. Readers of this report will likely have a better understanding of where the money went!
Conclusions

This report does not pretend to be an exhaustive analysis of the World Bank. There are many facets, examples and case studies that could be explored. In fact, many critical and analytical books have been written about the World Bank. The object of this report was to show how the World Bank fits into globalization as a central member in the triad of global monetary powers: The IMF, the BIS and the World Bank.

The World Bank is likely to continue to operate despite any amount of political flack or public protest. Such is the pattern of elitist-dominated institutions. Such is the history of the International Monetary Fund and the Bank for International Settlements.

It is sufficient to conclude that…

  • of the two architects of the World Bank, one was a top Soviet communist agent (Harry Dexter White) and the other was a British idealogue (John Maynard Keynes) totally dedicated to globalism (See Global Banking: The International Monetary Fund for more details on White and Keynes)
  • From the beginning, the Bank has been dominated by international banking interests and members of the Council on Foreign Relations and later by the Trilateral Commission
  • the cry of “poverty reduction” is a sham to conceal the recycling of billions of taxpayer dollars, if not trillions, into private hands
  • the cry of “poverty reduction” defuses critics of the Bank as being anti-poor and pro-poverty
  • corruption at the World Bank goes back decades, if not all the way to the very beginning

Footnotes

World Bank web site, About Page
The August Review, Global Banking: The International Monetary Fund
World Bank web site, IBRD Articles of Agreement: Article I
Stiglitz, Globalization and its Discontents (Norton, 2002), p. 234
ibid, p. 13
ibid
Wallach, Whose Trade Organization? (The New Press, 2004), p.125]
See also, Bechtel Vs. Bolivia: The Bolivian Water Revolt
See also, The New Yorker, letter on Leasing the Rain
See also, PBS, Leasing the Rain
World Bank web site, Bolivia Country Brief
Stiglitz, op. cit., p. 234
Lugar, U.S. Senate Website, $100 billion may have been lost to World Bank Corruption, May 13, 2004
ibid.
Hanaher, 50 Years is Enough: The Case Against the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, (South End Press, 1994), p. 10

11/06/2015

The secret currency union



Πηγή: Nikkei Asian Review
By Thomas Mayer
16 Oct 2015

What is the largest currency union of the world? The European Monetary Union, of course, you may think. Wrong. It is the U.S. dollar union. In an interesting paper, Robert McCauley and Tracy Chan of the Bank for International Settlement have shown that a large number of countries have more or less strongly pegged their currencies to the U.S. dollar ("Currency movements drive reserve composition", BIS Quarterly Review December 2014). 

According to their estimate, the U.S. dollar plays a key role for an area accounting for about 60 percent of global gross domestic product. Thus, the U.S. dollar zone is six times as large as the euro zone. As is customary in a currency union, many banks and companies in the U.S. dollar zone have assets and debt denominated in U.S. dollars. Like the European Central Bank in the euro zone the U.S. Federal Reserve determines financial conditions in the dollar zone.

As a result, developments have recently been similar in the two currency zones. When interest rates in other EMU countries fell to the low level of Germany at the beginning of the EMU, credit surged in these countries so that states and private entities became over-indebted. With the subsequent renewed rise in interest rates the credit bubble burst and pushed EMU into crisis. For members of the dollar zone interest rates plunged when the Federal Reserve fought the financial crisis triggered by the collapse of the subprime segment of the U.S. mortgage market. 

Like the countries of the euro zone before, the countries in the dollar zone then experienced a credit boom that also led to over-indebtedness. When the Fed ended its policy of quantitative easing and began musing about raising interest rates, the member countries of the dollar zone came under pressure.

The crisis in the dollar zone has not yet reached the intensity of the euro crisis. But the crisis there could broadly follow the script of the euro crisis. When states and banks in the euro zone were on the verge of financial collapse, stronger countries began to give financial assistance. But it was above all the ECB that stabilized the euro zone. The ECB assumed the role of lender of last resort to commercial banks and funded capital flight from the crisis countries through its interbank payment system (Target2). It also launched a program (dubbed outright monetary transactions or OMT) that turned it into a lender of last resort to troubled states.

In the dollar zone, similar capital movements from the periphery to the center have begun. Like in the euro zone this will create shortages in the refinancing of dollar denominated debt. In contrast to the ECB, however, the Fed has no mandate to support orderly payment flows in the dollar zone. But if the Fed stands on the sideline, a shortage of dollar funding could lead to the collapse of banks and companies in the periphery of the dollar zone. This could push the global economy into the next recession.

What could be done to prevent this? The International Monetary Fund and the World Bank warn against interest rate increases of the Fed. But zero rates and bloated central bank balance sheets can only push the problem into the future -- at the cost of magnifying it. Others want the Fed to provide dollar liquidity through swap agreements with other central banks of the dollar zone. 

But will the American public tolerate the accumulation of large claims of the Fed against shaky foreign central banks? This is unlikely. In the end, there will be only one solution: the unwinding of the dollar zone. This may well be painful, but a crisis can also pave the way to a new beginning. I do not know how this will look like. But two things seem likely to me: Central banks will be stripped of most of their power, and formal or informal currency unions will be out of favour.

Thomas Mayer is founding director of the Flossbach von Storch Research Institute in Cologne, Germany.


8/01/2012

What Happens to Greece’s Gold when They Exit the Eurozone


Πηγή: GoldSeek
By Julian D. W. Phillips
August 1 2012

Will Greece Exit the Eurozone?

With Germany’s leaders telling us that the exit from the Eurozone by Greece no longer holds terror for them, we understand that they are prepared for such an eventuality. As the E.U. leader’s representatives went to Greece this week to see the progress on the implementation of structural reforms and the austerity measures, it became clear to all that while we must wait for the results from them, Greece is failing in its efforts and further financing will be held beck for now, at least. Adding to the woes in Greece, there is little agreement within their Parliament. The Greek government is itself a broad mix of conservatives and Socialists.

In turn, the leaders of the European Commission, theInternational Monetary Fund and the European Central Bank, known as the troika, are increasingly divided among themselves. That is creating even more uncertainty as Greece and the rest of Europe head for yet another showdown, renewing doubts about how long Athens can remain within the Eurozone.

Greece’s lenders say they will not finance the country any further unless it meets its goals. But many experts say that the targets were never within reach and that pushing three increasingly weak Greek governments to comply has only profoundly damaged the economy. The belief in many quarters including in the Finance Ministry in Germany is that the exit of Greece from the Eurozone is almost certain now.

Officials from the troika overseeing the Greek bailout, the International Monetary Fund, the European Central Bank and the European Commission in Brussels, say privately that they doubt the country will be able to meet its official target of bringing its debt down to 120% of economic output by 2020. Greece must make the €3.1 billion in bond payments to the central bank on Aug. 20.

The European Commission reaffirmed that the next tranche of aid to Greece would probably not be disbursed until September, putting the country at greater risk of running out of money to pay salaries and pensions.

At the end of last week, the European Central Bank cut off a crucial source of cash for Greek banks, saying that it would stop accepting Greek government bonds as collateral for low-cost loans until the E.U. completes its report, which is not expected until late August at the earliest. Greek banks must now borrow from the Greek Central Bank at a higher interest rate, from a fund with limited means; if it runs out Greece would have to start printing drachmas.

The IMF, which indicated in March it won’t commit more money to Greece, will make a decision on its next disbursement in late August at the earliest based on the troika’s findings, said two fund officials familiar with the situation in recent days. The IMF has signalled to European officials that it will stop paying further rescue aid to Greece, bringing the country closer to insolvency in September. It’s “already clear” to the E.U. that Greece won’t reach the 120% target. Missing the targets means Greece would need between €10 billion and €50 billion in additional aid, a potential outcome that the IMF is not prepared to accept. The possibility that Greece could exit the 17- member monetary union has been voiced this year by European officials who consider the fallout from such a scenario would be the lesser evil against a seemingly perpetual crisis.

Greece’s economy shrank 3.5% in 2010 and 6.9% in 2011 and is expected to contract 7% this year, a decline reminiscent of the Great Depression of the 1930s. Unemployment is at 22.5% and expected to rise to 30%, while Greece’s main retailers’ association warned on Monday that sales were expected to drop 53% this year.

Greece, which held consecutive elections in May and June as public opposition to spending cuts grew, risks running out of money without the disbursement of €4.2 billion due last month as the first instalment of a €31 billion transfer.

The statements above and the increasingly ‘anti’ stance against Greece brings its exit to center stage. So it is sensible to look at what happens to it 111 tonnes of gold it holds in its Gold and Foreign Exchange reserves currently.

Where’s Greece’s Gold?

The 111 tonnes of gold owned by Greece is in one of three central banks and perhaps spread throughout the three. These banks are the Bank of England, the Banque de France and the U.S. Federal Reserve. We are of the opinion [the Bank of International Settlements would never disclose the facts] that Greece’s gold was first used in some of the over 500 tonnes of gold/currency swaps executed two years ago and unwound last year by the B.I.S.

We believe, further, that these swaps were undertaken by nations finding it difficult to raise new loans at reasonable interest rates. The gold/currency swaps were undertaken as part of the collateral creditors required to facilitate new loans. As such their value went far beyond the market price of the gold involved.

When Greece required a generous bailout from E.U. creditors we were led to believe that part of the collateral, to be forfeited on default, was the 111 tonnes of gold owned by Greece. It is this gold that is now in danger of being lost to the nation now.

The fact that it is not in the country has allowed it to be possessed by central banks outside the country that would not hesitate to hand the gold over, on default by Greece.

Why a Nation’s Gold is Not Held at Home

It may come as a surprise that the bulk of the world’s central banks do not hold their nation’s gold in vaults at home. It has been this way for most of the last century. While the reputations of the three central banks are impeccable, nevertheless, with the world in the financial state it is in now, it seems a matter of prudence that gold should not be in the possession of foreign central banks. After all when push comes to shove, possession is nine tenths of the law.

This became a worry last year to Venezuela who is not the darling of the U.S. at the moment. Its gold was held in several central banks, including the bank of England. President Chavez, on the advice of his central bank decided to repatriate Venezuela’s gold. It was a cumbersome exercise but it was done and is now held in Venezuela out of the reach of those unhappy with its nationalization policies. After all there is always a case to be made for creditors whose assets have been seized to be given recourse to the country assets held outside the country. This is an increasing danger in a world where the value of sovereign debt is in doubt in so many countries.

One of the key reasons for holding gold is to be able to sell it to provide the nation with access to international trade and loans, when its creditworthiness and its currency are unacceptable outside the country. By holding the gold outside the country that gold may well have been appropriated by other nations. We have seen of late this happen to Iran, all of whose foreign assets have been frozen with attempts being made to freeze its oil exports. Whether justified or not, the vulnerability of a nation’s assets should be a factor considered by the government and central bank of every nation. To allow their assets to be vulnerable to seizure is an act of imprudence to say the least.

Should Greece forfeit its gold as a consequence of its default, then it will be, we expect, at market prices only. The ability to use its value far above its price by way of collateral in gold swaps to facilitate loans and lower interest rates will have been lost entirely. We believe that it is part of a central banker’s duty to handle their nation’s assets to the full benefit of the nation. That requires that the gold be in its own possession not in the hands of others who may seize it because of a policy disagreement no matter how serious it may be perceived.

If Greece Leaves Then What Next?

Greece will, we believe have to leave the European currency entirely, just as Argentina did in the nineties. After all, the massive loss of creditworthiness will necessitate a devaluation of the currency. That won’t happen by continuing to use the euro. A glance at history shows that in this case it is possible that a value of 50% of the Euro be attributed to the Drachma. In addition there will have to be a block put on capital exports from Greece. After that we would expect to see a “Financial Drachma” [ort whatever name the Greek central bank gives it] in addition to a “Commercial Drachma” instituted in Greece as Capital and Exchange Controls are put in place to protect what’s left of the financial viability of Greece.

The “Commercial Drachma” would be used for normal trade activities of import and export of good and for tourism. The “Financial Drachma” would be for capital flows both in and out of the country. We may well go into more detail once these events have happened, but for now let’s leave it as a currency that could easily fall by another 30% against the “Commercial Drachma” [say 35% of the exchange rate value of the euro]. In another article, we may well paint the huge advantages to Greece of operating such a system.

In addition we may well see a system of “debt Conversion” being instituted within Greece to incentivize investment into Greece for infrastructural development and other projects that would benefit the nation.



12/01/2011

Korea: '54% of banks’ borrowing from Europe'


Πηγή: Korea Times
By Kang Seung-woo
Dec 1 2011

Korean banks are heavily dependent on Europe in their overseas borrowing, as more than half of their debts stemmed from counterparts on the continent in the first half of this year, data showed Thursday.

Given that the eurozone sovereign debt crisis is still raging, the heavy European reliance is raising concerns of a possible liquidity shortage of foreign currency.

According to the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), Korean banks’ borrowing from European banks recorded $187.25 billion, accounting for 53.6 percent of their total debts of $349.46 billion as of the end of June.

By country, Britain was the largest lender with $100.48 billion, followed by France with $32.58 billion and Germany with $19.95 billion, according to the BIS.

Market watchers are worried that Asia’s fourth-largest economy may suffer a lack of foreign currency liquidity if Europe’s debt turmoil spreads to other countries and the continent’s lenders try to take back the money.

“Austria recently decided to limit loan extensions to Eastern Europe. This shows that countries with top credit ratings may move to reduce overseas liquidity in a bid to retain their grades," Lee Seung-ho, a researcher at the Korea Capital Market Institute, was quoted as saying by Yonhap News Agency.

He also said that local firms and financial institutions have to make efforts to maintain their foreign currency liquidity ratio at an optimum level if European banks request their money in a worst-case scenario.

The data comes as the eurozone debt problems are causing a headache for neighboring countries, showing signs of spreading to France and Germany, the top two strongest economies in the region.

Earlier this year, with the financial turmoil hitting the markets hard, President Lee Myung-bak told banks to diversify their financing sources to include more Middle Eastern loans, rather than just relying on Europe.

However, the nation’s financial watchdog said that the borrowing from Europe is currently manageable.

“If the European debt problem enters a dangerous phase, euro funds can exit Korea, but as most debts have contracts, it is hard for them to be called in ahead of their expiration,” said an official of the Financial Supervisory Service (FSS).

“But the FSS is encouraging banks to lower their dependence on Europe in their borrowing following the region’s crisis.”


8/28/2011

London: City gears up to kill new finance tax


Battle lines are being drawn as the City of London prepares to resist European attempts to introduce new bank taxes.


Πηγή: The Bureau of Investigative Journalism
By Nick Mathiason
August 26th, 2011


Hostilities kicked off last week when Angela Merkel and Nicholas Sarkozy redoubled efforts to harmonise EU tax rates and levy a tiny financial transaction tax on financial trades of around 0.05%.

The French and German leaders united in a twin track attempt to recoup the hundreds of billions of euros spent bailing out failed banks and the bankrupt national economies of Portugal, Ireland and Greece. They were also driven to reassert a semblance of authority over financial markets.

Death knell of the financial sector?

The City lobbying machine went into overdrive in a ferocious attempt to garner support from David Cameron’s government, against the proposals that they, rather dramatically, claim will kill the country’s financial sector.

The billions that would be skimmed off City profits into Treasury coffers by the banking levy amount to little more than loose change to a sector where $1.8 trillion is traded on a daily basis on London’s foreign exchange markets.

Buoyed by huge injections of public money into capital markets known as quantitative easing, banks and hedge funds have been making huge profits. They have feasted on currencies, commodities, sovereign debt and equities both in the two-year share rally after the economic crash of 2008 and in the recent sell-off thanks to the practice of shorting (borrowing shares, selling them and buying back after the price has fallen).

At the same time wider European and United States’ economies have flat-lined sparking high unemployment, high inflation and increased social unrest.

Bank tax is loose change

Against this backdrop, European politicians are increasingly emboldened to create a long-term banking tax by placing a small levy on each individual transaction on financial markets.

France and Germany are effectively attempting to claw back some of the cash governments were forced to hand over to prop up the world’s economy after footloose, lightly regulated financiers brought it to near collapse.

The City of London has the most to lose with 36.7% of all global currency transactions – the first trading area likely to be taxed under the new proposals – taking place in the Square Mile.

A micro-tax on all currency could be worth as much as £20bn.

While seemingly large, however, the billions that would be skimmed off City profits into Treasury coffers, amount to little more than loose change, to a sector where $1.8 trillion is traded on a daily basis just on London’s Forex markets.

The Square Mile Money Machine

The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) last year stated the total turnover on foreign exchange markets worldwide has now reached $4 trillion a day.

Forex trading in the UK is $1.8 trillion which is 36.7% of global market share. The UK’s market share is more than double the United States in second place.

The London Stock Exchange is the fourth largest domestic equity market capitalised exchange in the world.

London is the most active Eurobonds trading centre. New notes issued in London last year totalled £416.6bn.

BIS data shows that the UK is the leading financial derivatives market. Of the entire $2.7tn global daily turnover, $1.23tn is traded in the UK every day equivalent to a 45.8% market share.


‘Economic suicide’

Yet City big shots have come out in force against the Franco-German proposals arguing that any tax on banking would destroy London’s pre-eminence and undermine mainstream businesses.

Last weekend Michael Spencer, a former Conservative Party treasurer and one of the most influential figures in the Square Mile, in an interview with the Independent on Sunday stated: ‘It would be economic suicide if the UK agreed to this tax.’

‘It would be economic suicide if the UK agreed to this tax.’
Michael Spencer, former Conservative party treasurer

It did not go un-noted that Spencer also, effectively, called on the loyal support of his old friends in government. ‘I know that David Cameron and George Osborne will not fall for this as it will destroy the City of London,’ he added.

Spencer may be basing his confidence on the tens of millions of pounds donated by his City comrades to the Tory party. Earlier this year, the Bureau revealed that in the five years since Cameron became leader, City lucre has poured into Conservative headquarters going from 25% of all the party’s funds to 50.8% in 2010.

Spencer’s observation was followed the next day by Simon Lewis, chief executive of the Association for Financial Markets in Europe, a lobby group representing the world’s biggest banks.

The rich get richer

Writing in the Daily Mail, Lewis argued the idea of a financial transaction tax has been around for 40 years and ‘with good reason, the proposal has never been taken up’.

Since the crash there has been little meaningful reform on bankers’ pay, tax abuse and transparency in markets, despite wide public desire that the City should be made to pay for some of the mess western economies are now in.

And while many economies hang in the balance, profits in many financial sectors are back up to pre-crash levels and bankers’ pay is back in the stratosphere.

But the City lobby is powerful. And with Spencer effectively challenging the Conservative party to stay loyal to its City paymasters and side against the European proposals, Merkel and Sarkozy are going to need great powers of persuasion to force the EU financial tax agenda beyond the Eurozone and into London’s markets.


8/08/2011

"From Saddam to Stiglitz": Heading Towards a Global Currency?




It is hardly a coincidence that following Saddam Hussein who was eager to replace the dollar with euro as the currency for oil trade Qaddafi was like minded operating back in 2007 along the OPEC with the Iranian and Venezuelan presidents,  Mahmud Ahmadinejad and Hugo Chavez . On 2009 appointed as the new chairman of the African Union he was complaining about the losses from the barrel – dollar connection intending to create a new Pan – African currency while talking about the need of this replacement with the BIRCS. But he wasn’t alone.


By the September of the same year, for the first time, the UN Conference of Trade and Development produced a radical report that emphasized the same considerations in the aftermath of the economic crises of 2008. While other countries like China and Russia had suggested replacing the dollar this was the first time that an international organization pointed to the same direction claiming that the present system, under which the dollar acts as the world’s reserve currency should be subject to a wholesale reconsideration. On March Russia had proposed the creation of a new currency backed by China to be issued by international financial institutions, among other measures in the text of its proposals to the April G20 summit.

On February 2011 the IMF and its head Dominique Strauss – Kahn expressed the same opinion. In his speech in Washington he stated that the reserves that member countries held with the fund could be used, instead of the dollar, to price international trade. These so-called special drawing rights (SDRs) could also act as an alternative to the dollar in central banks' foreign currency reserves. Of course this was before the recent scandal broke up depriving him from his position. By the same time China launched trading in her own currency as for the first time as the state controlled Bank of China LTD allowed customers to trade the yuan, Known as renminbi, in the US.

 On April the well-known Nobel - prize winning economist Joseph Stiglitz said at Columbia University that the existing monetary system means “there’s a very good risk of an extended period of low growth, inflationary bias, instability”… “It’s a system that’s fundamentally unfair because it means that poor countries are lending to the U.S. at close to zero interest rates.” He also emphasized that a “global system” is needed to replace the dollar as a reserve currency and help avoid a weakening of U.S. credit quality. 
Stiglitz  took part in the  INET Bretton Woods summit, summoned by George Soros where “New ideas for a New World” were presented while Soros have expressed the possibility for the replacement of dollar in his book “"The Crash of 2008 and What it Means" back in 2009. 


By the same time (April 2011) the development banks of the five BIRCS’ nations agreed to establish mutual credit lines denominated by in their local currencies , not the U.S. currency. The BIRCS accounting for 40% of global population and 20% of global GDP in their third summit in the southern Chinese island of Hainan released a declaration in which among others stated that “We welcome the current discussion about the role of the SDR in the existing international monetary system including the composition of SDR's basket of currencies”.

To the present the most appropritate regulator fostering international monetary and financial cooperation and serving as a bank for central banks is the Bank for International Settlements (BIS).  Although two of the key players for its establishment back in 1930 were the then-Governor of The Bank of England, Montagu Norman, and his German counterpart Hjalmar Schacht, later Adolf Hitler's finance minister, and despite that after World War II was accused by the US and others for helping the Germans looting assets from occupied countries, BIS through the British intervention and the death of Roosevelt managed to avoid liquidation and now is still alive and kicking.  The BIS have recommended the “new currency scheme” in its annual report commemorating its founding back in 2005.

The Post – Cold War era in which we live gave us the opportunity to see the “power to the people” slogan in action: First some US citizens striving to “get a roof above their heads”,  as we say in Greece for someone who’s buying his first house, managed to put in serious threat the global economy and then the Greek plumber  – well Known for not declaring properly his income – along with the lazy Greek worker managed to almost destroy the Eurozone. It remains to be seen if at the end of the tunnel a new global currency will emerge…