Showing posts with label Saif al-Islam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Saif al-Islam. Show all posts

8/21/2020

Demonstrations held in support of Gaddafi family in 3 Libyan cities

 



Source: AMN
August 20 2020
By News Desk


BEIRUT, LEBANON (11:00 P.M.) – Dozens of people gathered inside three Libyan cities this week to demonstrate in support of Saif Al-Islam Al-Gaddafi, the son of the former president, Mu’ammar Al-Gaddafi.

According to Al-Wasat, the demonstrations were held in the cities of Sirte, Bani Walid, and Ghat, which are located in north-central Libya.

The participants reportedly held photos of the former Libyan President, along with his sons, Saif Al-Islam, Mu’tassem, and Khamis.

The protesters were reportedly calling for the return of Saif Al-Islam to Libyan politics, while announcing their support for his presidency.

The city of Sirte is the birthplace of Mu’ammar Gaddafi and was one of the main strongholds for the late president during the first phase of the Libyan Civil War.

Since Gaddafi’s death, the city has been controlled by the Government of National Accord, Libyan National Army, and Islamic State (ISIS/ISIL/IS/Daesh).

Sirte is currently under the control of the Libyan National Army and has been since they captured the city from the Government of National Accord in January 2020.

The Government of National Accord is now eyeing the recapture of the city, despite the Egyptian government’s announcement that Sirte is their “red line”.


7/11/2016

Gaddafi son Saif al-Islam wants to 'contribute to unification of Libya'



Πηγή: France24
8 Jule 2016


The embattled son of the late Libyan strongman Muammar Gaddafi was released from jail several weeks ago and has been living in the town of Zintan, his lawyers have told FRANCE 24.

Saif al-Islam – once widely regarded as Gaddafi’s likeliest successor – was sentenced to death in 2015 for crimes committed during the revolution that overthrew his father. He has nevertheless been allowed to walk free under an amnesty provision by the Libyan government as it struggles to unite the country.

Lawyer Marcel Ceccaldi on Friday confirmed his client had left jail on April 12, 2016 as originally reported by FRANCE 24, adding that he was not serving time under house arrest.

Ceccaldi said Saif al-Islam wanted to “contribute to the political unification of Libya” and “fight against terrorism,” in reference to the Islamic State group, which has taken over key parts of the north African country.

Another lawyer, Karim Khan, said Wednesday that Saif al-Islam was released under an amnesty declared by the Tobruk parliament, the internationally recognised authority that governed part of Libya before the national unity government of Fayez al-Sarraj took over in March.

The lawyer said the release was made "in accordance with (Libyan) law".

Khan declined to say whether he had spoken to his client, saying only that he "is well and safe and in Libya".

Saif al-Islam had been held since 2011 by a militia in Zintan, a mountainous western region beyond the control of authorities in the capital, Tripoli.

His captors refused to transfer him to Tripoli, where he was sentenced to death in absentia by a court in the city in July 2015 for his part in the killing of protesters during the uprising that toppled his father.

The verdict had drawn condemnation abroad, with Human Rights Watch saying the trial was riddled with legal flaws and carried out amid widespread lawlessness undermining the credibility of the judiciary.

To challenge ICC charges

The proceedings began in April 2014 before fighting between rival factions in Tripoli erupted, and the power struggle has loomed large in the unravelling of state authority around the vast, oil-producing North African country.

Saif al-Islam is also wanted by the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague, which issued an arrest warrant in 2011 on preliminary charges of crimes against humanity, murder and persecution for being part of the inner circle of his father’s regime.

Khan said he would file an application to make the ICC case inadmissible, arguing that his client has already been tried by his home country.

Invoking the principle of "double jeopardy", he said: "It is prohibited to try an individual twice for the same offense".

Asked whether dropping charges against Saif al-Islam would hurt reconciliation efforts in the war-torn country, the lawyer said it was "up to Libyans to decide what is best for peace and reconciliation", not the ICC.

According to a source quoted by French daily Le Monde, he has been living in Zintan in a “comfortable house with a new wife and their three-year-old daughter”, and able to move around freely.

5/31/2013

International Court: Libya, Give up Gadhafi Son


Πηγή: abc NEWS
By TOBY STERLING, Associated Press
May 31 2013

International Criminal Court judges on Friday rejected Libya's request to annul the international arrest warrant for the son of the late Moammar Gadhafi and let the country's new government try him in Tripoli.

In essence, the ICC found the Libyan government is not capable of holding a fair trial for Seif al-Islam Gadhafi itself, and judges said the country's new leaders are obliged under international law to hand him over to the court in The Hague, Netherlands.

Whether the government in Tripoli will be willing — or able — to transfer Gadhafi to The Hague are both open questions. Gadhafi was captured by a militia group as he was trying to flee to neighboring Niger in the aftermath of Libya's 20th11 civil war.

With no national army or police in place since the fall of Gadhafi's regime, successive governments have been too weak to secure Seif al-Islam's transfer to Tripoli.

Seif is jailed in the town of Zintan, and the Abu Bakr al-Sadek militia group has itself begun trial proceedings against Seif for charges including insulting the new country's flag and "harming state security."

The Hague court wants him for alleged crimes against humanity in the murder and persecution of protesters in the uprising that ultimately toppled his father's regime in 2011. The Libyan government wants him for somewhat similar charges, though judges also said Friday the charges aren't similar enough to warrant canceling the international case.

Gadhafi says he is innocent of wrongdoing.

"The Libyan state continues to face substantial difficulties in exercising fully its judicial powers across the entire territory," presiding judge Silvia Fernandez de Gurmendi said in a written summary of Friday's decision.

He added that "Libyan authorities have not been able to secure the transfer of (Gadhafi) into state custody and impediments remain to obtain the necessary evidence, and secure legal representation."

According to filings by defense lawyers at the ICC, Seif al-Islam has said he wants to be tried for alleged war crimes in the Netherlands.

"I am not afraid to die, but if you execute me after such a trial, you should just call it murder," he said.

The Hague court does not have a death penalty.

Although Libya is not a member of the ICC, the case was referred to the court by the U.N. Security Council.

"Libya has until now operated according to the ICC's procedures, as the U.N. Security Council required," said Richard Dicker, international justice director at Human Rights Watch. "By respecting the ICC's judicial process, the authorities will send an important message about their commitment to the rule of law."

Moammar Gadhafi was killed in Sirte, Libya, in October 2011 by victorious rebel forces. Seif was captured a month later in a southern desert region and later moved to Zintan, in the western coastal mountains.

The rest of Seif al-Islam's family, including his mother, his sister, two brothers and others, were granted asylum in Oman in March, moving there from Algeria, where they found refuge during the civil war.


1/21/2013

ICC lawyers slam Libya over Gaddafi son


Πηγή: news
Jan 21 2013

LAWYERS defending Muammar Gaddafi's son, Saif al-Islam, at the International Criminal Court have accused Libyan authorities of conducting a "Kafka-esque show trial" after he appeared in a court in his homeland for the first time last week.

The latest broadside in the legal tug-of-war between The Hague-based ICC and Tripoli over where Gaddafi, 40, should face justice came after he appeared in the dock in the Libyan town of Zintan on Thursday on charges of "undermining state security".

The Libyan charges were levelled after four ICC envoys went to Zintan in June and were detained for nearly a month, triggering a diplomatic row.

One of the four, Australian lawyer Melinda Taylor, was accused of carrying a pen camera and attempting to give Gaddafi a coded letter from his former right-hand man, Mohammed Ismail, who is wanted by Libyan authorities.

After Gaddafi appeared in court, ICC lawyers on Monday submitted an urgent request to the ICC "to issue an immediate decision on the admissibility of the case, and to order the government of Libya to immediately surrender Mr Gaddafi to the custody of the ICC".

The ICC is mulling a Libyan request to put Gaddafi and former spy chief Abdullah Senoussi on trial there, while the ICC itself wants to try Gaddafi on charges of crimes against humanity committed in the conflict that overthrew his father in 2011.

The ICC lawyers said Gaddafi "is essentially being tried for attempting to communicate with the ICC via his counsel in relation to the fact that his rights had been violated".

"Prosecuting a defendant for trying to defend himself epitomises the very definition of a Kafka-esque show trial."

The ICC lawyers said Gaddafi's trial on security charges was "a completely unrelated, and abusive prosecution".

"Such strong-arm tactics have absolutely no place in a court of law or in any country which claims to respect the rule of law."

The ICC, mandated by the UN Security Council to investigate the Libyan conflict, issued arrest warrants in June 2011 for both Gaddafi and Senoussi on charges of crimes against humanity.

Lawyers for the two accused have said they will not get a fair trial in Libya, which has until Wednesday to submit its latest report to the ICC in a bid to have the court quash a surrender request.

10/10/2012

Gaddafi son 'will be hanged in Libya', defence tells ICC

ICC wants Seif Gaddafi to be tried in The Hague but Libyan authorities insist he should stand trial in his home country.
Πηγή: The Indian Express
Oct 10 2012

Muammar Gaddafi's son Seif al-Islam without a doubt would get a death sentence if tried in Libya, his lawyer told the Hague-based International Criminal Court today.

"Although the Libyan government has danced around the issue, let's be very clear: if convicted (in Libya) Mr Gaddafi will be hanged," Melinda Taylor, a court-appointed lawyer, told judges amid a dispute on where Seif should face justice.

While the ICC wants Seif, the only son of the slain Libyan leader in custody, to be tried in The Hague, Libya's post-revolutionary authorities insist he should stand trial in his home country.

Libya's lawyers told a three-judge bench yesterday the country had enough evidence to charge Seif with crimes against humanity, committed when Gaddafi and his loyalists tried to put down Libya's bloody revolution last year.

But the lawyers admitted although Tripoli was committed to a fair trial for Gaddafi, it was a "complicated process and that Libya needed more time."

Taylor, a member of the ICC's defence office, said Gaddafi's right to a fair trial was being violated while he is held in isolation in the northwestern Libyan hilltown of Zintan, where he has been in custody since his arrest on November 19.

The ICC issued arrest warrants for Seif, 40 and Gaddafi's former spymaster Abdullah Senussi, 63, in June 2011 on two counts of crimes against humanity committed while trying to crush the uprising that ended over four decades of Gaddafi's iron-fisted rule.

But the ICC's jurisdiction is complementary to that of national courts, and it can only act when a member state is unwilling or unable to do so. The court's judges are to make a ruling on the issue at an unspecified later date.

Taylor yesterday cited a law passed by Libya's post-revolutionary National Transitional Council which said no child of Gaddafi will ever benefit from leniency.

Putting Gaddafi on trial will "not be motivated by a desire for justice but a desire for revenge," Taylor told today's hearing, adding that both Seif and Senussi – extradited from Mauritania last month – were yet to appear before a judge.

"Mr Gaddafi is not a guinea pig (for Libyan justice). He is a person with rights. He should not be languishing in prison while Libya tries to build a judicial system," she said.

The ICC is the world's only permanent criminal tribunal set up to try genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes.



8/01/2012

Gaddafi son cannot get fair trial in Libya: lawyers

Saif al-Islam is seen after his capture, in the custody of revolutionary fighters in Obari, Libya November 19, 2011.

Πηγή: Reuters
By Thomas Escritt
July 31 2012

Slain Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi's son Saif al-Islam cannot get a fair trial in Libya and he claims if he is executed it would be tantamount to murder, his defense lawyers said on Tuesday in a filing to the International Criminal Court (ICC).

"I am not afraid to die but if you execute me after such a trial you should just call it murder and be done with it," Saif al-Islam said, according to his lawyers, referring to a possible trial in Libya, where he is being detained by tribesmen.

An ICC defense lawyer and three other staff were detained by local authorities in Libya's western mountain city of Zintan in June after meeting Saif al-Islam, prompting frantic attempts to secure their release.

During that June meeting, Saif al-Islam's court-appointed lawyer was prevented from taking a sworn statement by an official who had been posing as an illiterate guard, they said.

"The 'guard', who is actually Mr. Ahmed Amer - a councilor who speaks several languages - was planted in the room to deliberately trick the delegation," the filing said.

"He came back into the room and (in the presence of the ICC interpreter), started shouting that this statement was very dangerous, violated Libyan national security, and that the Defence could not have it back."

British-educated Saif al-Islam is wanted by the ICC for allegedly ordering terror and killings during the two-week uprising that brought down his father. Libya wants to try Saif al-Islam in its own courts and is resisting attempts to transfer him to The Hague.

Lawyers said their meeting with Saif al-Islam was cut short after 45 minutes, and that the guard confiscated documents they needed to consult with him about, including his sworn statement.

Melinda Taylor, Saif al-Islam's court-appointed lawyer, her Lebanese interpreter, and two other staff, from Russia and Spain, were held for 26 days after the meeting.

"The sole rationale for doing so appears to be that the Libyan authorities consider it to be illegal, treason, or a violation of national security for either Mr. Gaddafi or his Counsel to indicate that Mr. Gaddafi does not wish to be tried before Libyan courts," the lawyers said in the filing.

Zintan authorities accused Taylor and her Lebanese interpreter of endangering national security by bringing sensitive documents to Saif al-Islam, a charge they deny.

The defence team accused the Libyans of using their detention to influence the outcome of the Libyan elections.




7/06/2012

Saif al-Islam Gaddafi will not get fair trial, says lawyer

Both the ICC and Libya want to put Saif al-Islam Gaddafi on trial for crimes under the former regime.

Πηγή: BBC
July 6 2012

Muammar Gaddafi's son will not get a fair trial in Libya, an international lawyer has said, days after she was released from detention in the country.

International Criminal Court lawyer Melinda Taylor said Saif al-Islam's right to a fair trial had been "irrevocably prejudiced".

Ms Taylor was held for four weeks in Libya on suspicion of spying as she visited the son of Libya's ex-ruler.

Saif al-Islam Gaddafi has been indicted by the ICC for crimes against humanity.

But Libya is insisting he should be tried at home.

On Friday, Ms Taylor said that her actions in Libya were "consistent with my legal obligations" under ICC rules.

"Irrespective of any issues concerning my own personal conduct, the rights of my client, Mr Saif al-Islam, were irrevocably prejudiced during my visit," she said.

This was the first time the Australian lawyer has spoken publicly following her release on Monday.

Ms Taylor and three other ICC staff had been accused of spying while visiting Saif al-Islam in the town of Zintan.

They are still scheduled to appear before a court in Tripoli on 23 July for a final ruling on their case, a senior member of the Libyan attorney-general's office told the BBC.



6/26/2012

Law of the jungle in post-Gadhafi Libya


Πηγή: thestar
By Eric Morse
June 25 2012

Fresh from last month’s triumph in getting a war crimes conviction against deposed Liberian president Charles Taylor, the International Criminal Court now has its hand caught in a bear trap in Libya.

On June 9, Melinda Taylor, an Australian senior lawyer for the court in The Hague and three of her colleagues were detained in Zintan, west of Tripoli, by Libyan “authorities” on charges of “espionage.” The claim is that she was “carrying suspicious documents” for Moammar Gadhafi’s captured son Saif al-Islam. According to Reuters, the “authorities” elaborated that “the lawyer had a letter written in English that they wanted him to sign admitting that there is no law in Libya and asking to be transferred to the ICC.”

Things became clearer June 11 when those holding her said she would be released if she led them to a key former regime figure linked to Saif al-Islam. Taylor is alleged to have had this individual’s GPS co-ordinates on her.

Put baldly, it’s a ransom demand which also, as Andrew McGregor of the Washington security think-tank Jamestown Foundation notes, sends a message to the ICC — “the Gadhafis belong to us.”

The ICC group was not detained by “Libyan authorities.” They are being held by the Zintan militia, one of the most heavily armed and independent formations in the country, whose relations with the internationally recognized National Transitional Council in Tripoli are (at best) strained. In fact, the NTC’s control even in Tripoli itself is actively contested. But most of the players in Libya agree that they want to deal with the Gadhafis themselves, and not turn them over to international justice. The Australian foreign minister has come and gone from Tripoli empty-handed.

The affair underscores that post-Gadhafi Libya is a chaotic place with no effective government, and that ICC officials with the temerity to go there are under threat. That is something new and very dangerous.

The detainees also appear to be victims of infighting within the ICC itself. Taylor’s ex-colleagueSeth Engel has said in a Huffington Post piece that her group was actually there as representatives of the ICC Office of Public Counsel for Defence (OPCD — the defence lawyers in any eventual trial), and that they were caught offside in a spat with Chief ProsecutorLuis Moreno Ocampo, who has taken the very odd position that the Libyans are entitled to try Gadhafi junior at home.

Yet Taylor’s group was in Zintan to prepare for Saif Gadhafi’s eventual defence, which raises the fundamental question: What on earth were they thinking of? The other question would be, who let them go there under those conditions — the likely answer is that one silo of the court does not answer to another.

Moreno Ocampo, who retires at the end of next month, is known for international grandstanding. He is also not known for backing down on ICC claims of right to prosecute. In early May, the OPCD accused Moreno Ocampo of having biased the case against Gadhafi by declaring that Saif al-Islam was guilty; the OPCD demanded Moreno Ocampo’s removal from the file. Moreno Ocampo had also hinted he had struck a deal with Tripoli to let Gadhafi be tried in Libya — while also asserting that no side in Libya is immune from war crimes investigation, quite rightly given the atrocities that we know have been going on in the country.

It’s one thing to assert the supremacy of the court. It’s quite another to be so ignorant of the situation on the ground — or so breathtakingly arrogant — as to send four civilians into what are effectively ungoverned lands and expect that nothing will happen.

Engel calls what is going on in Zintan “summary justice,” but it’s more than that. It’s a demonstration of complete breakdown of order in Libya — hardly surprising after Moammar Gadhafi’s fall. The outcome in Libya post-Gadhafi is not much different from the outcome in Iraq post-Saddam, with the exception that this time the West managed to keep its boots off the ground.

None of which is of any help to Taylor, or to the credibility of international justice.

Eric Morse is a former Canadian diplomat, now vice-chair of security studies at the Royal Canadian Military Institute in Toronto.



6/14/2012

NATO chief urges ICC team release in Libya


Πηγή: abc-cbn news
By AFP
June 14 2012

SYDNEY - NATO chief Anders Fogh Rasmussen on Thursday expressed "strong regret" at the detention of an International Criminal Court delegation in Libya and urged their swift release.

"I strongly regret that certain groups in Libya have arrested or withheld representatives of the International Criminal Court and I would urge them to release those individuals as soon as possible," the Secretary General said in Australia.

Rasmussen noted that the "new authorities in Libya have co-operated in a positive manner" with the ICC, which he hoped augured well for the quick release of the four-person team, which includes Australian Melinda Taylor.

Taylor and her colleagues from Lebanon, Russia and Spain were detained last week after meeting with Seif al-Islam, the son of slain Libyan dictator Moamer Kadhafi, to help him choose a defense lawyer.

The Hague-based ICC wants to try Seif, 39, for crimes against humanity.

Libyan officials have alleged Taylor was carrying a pen camera and attempting to give Seif a coded letter from his former right-hand man Mohammed Ismail, who is on the run.

Australia has said that Taylor and the other three are entitled to immunity but warned Wednesday there appeared little chance of their early release, with indications that Libyan authorities may seek to hold them for 45 days.

On Tuesday, Libyan government spokesman Mohammed al-Harizi told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation that Taylor would be freed if she gave them information on Ismail.

"We want this guy. It is very important to catch this guy because this guy is very, very, very danger(ous) for us," he said, and claimed Taylor had met with Ismail, given that she had a letter from him.



6/11/2012

International Criminal Court staff members detained in Libya


Πηγή: WW4report
By Jurist
June 11 2012

The International Criminal Court (ICC) said June 9 that four ICC staff members have been detained in Libya since Thursday the 7th. They traveled to Libya on the 6th to meet with Saif al-Islam Qaddafi, the son of Moammar Qaddafi. Reportedly among the detainees are Melinda Taylor, an Australian lawyer working for the ICC. A representative for the Libyan courts said that Taylor attempted to give documents to Saif al-Islam that were from his former aid, Mohammed Ismail, who has been in hiding since the Libyan conflict began. She was therefore found to pose a threat to Libyan safety.

ICC president Judge Sang-Hyun Song called for their immediate release:

We are very concerned about the safety of our staff in the absence of any contact with them. These four international civil servants have immunity when on an official ICC mission. I call on the Libyan authorities to immediately take all necessary measures to ensure their safety and security and to liberate them.

The ICC is currently in communication with Libyan authorities.

Last week a pre-trial chamber of the ICC granted a request by the Libyan government to postpone an order to transfer Saif al-Islam to ICC custody. The issue of which court is going to try Saif al-Islam has been in dispute since he was captured by Libyan rebel forces in November. In April ICC chief prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo stated that the maximum penalty for Saif al-Islam in the ICC would be life in prison, but if convicted in a national court he could face the death penalty. Earlier that month Ocampo asked the ICC to report Libya to the UN Security Council for failing to turn over Saif al-Islam. Libya expressly denied the ICC's request for such action and stated that Saif al-Islam will face trial within the country.

In February 2011, the UN Security Council voted unanimously to refer the matter in Libya to the ICC prosecutor. The ICC claimed jurisdiction over Saif al-Islam despite its announcement in November that it may allow Libya to conduct the trial.





4/05/2012

ICC rejects Libya request over Gaddafi son's surrender


Πηγή: Emirates 247
By Reuters
April 5 2012

The International Criminal Court (ICC) on Wednesday ordered Libya to immediately hand over for trial Saif Al Islam Gaddafi, the son of the late Libyan leader, but Libya's new authorities said they still wanted to try him themselves.

The court in The Hague ordered Tripoli to "comply with its obligations to enforce the warrant of arrest" and surrender him into the court's custody without delay, rejecting a Libyan request to delay the handover.

The ICC says it has jurisdiction in the case and that a U.N. Security Council Resolution obliges Libya to co-operate. It has warned that Tripoli's failure to hand Saif Al Islam over could result in it being reported to the Council.

Along with human rights organisations, it harbours concerns about the fairness of Libya's new justice system.

Since the elder Gaddafi was killed after being captured alive by rebel fighters, competing militias have yet to lay down their arms and Western human rights organisations have accused them of carrying out numerous extra-judicial executions and other abuses, raising serious questions about the rule of law.

The ICC issued a warrant for Saif Al Islam in June last year, after prosecutors accused him and others of involvement in the killing of protesters during the revolt that eventually toppled and killed his father, Muammar Gaddafi, in August.

But Libya says Gaddafi's son should face justice at home. He was caught last year disguised as a Bedouin tribesman in the Sahara desert, months after telling his father's opponents they would be exterminated like rats.

He faces the death penalty if found guilty by a Libyan court, but only a prison term if convicted by the ICC.

LIBYA POSITION UNCHANGED

In the Libyan capital Tripoli, a spokesman for the government which took over after Muammar Gaddafi's fall did not comment directly on the ICC decision but said the plan to try Saif Al Islam inside Libya remained unchanged.

"The justice ministry announces that the central prison preparations have been completed. They are ready for the trial of Saif Al Islam and it will be soon," the spokesman, Nasser Al Manee, told a news conference.

As soon as construction work on a special prison in Tripoli is completed, Libyan authorities say Saif Al Islam will be moved there and that his trial will start.

Up until now he has been held in the western Libyan town of Zintan by the militia that captured him.

The ICC also says it has jurisdiction over the case because it formally issued warrants last year for the arrest of Muammar Gaddafi, Saif Al Islam, and the Libyan leader's intelligence chief, Abdullah Al Senussi, who was arrested last month in Mauritania.

Saif Al Islam's supporters say they doubt he will be given a fair trial in Libya and would prefer him to be tried by the ICC.

\New York-based Human Rights Watch (HRW) also believes Saif Al Islam would receive a fairer and safer trial in the Netherlands.

"Today's decision means that ... the authorities (in Libya) must start making arrangements to surrender Saif al-Islam to the court," said Richard Dicker, HRW's international justice program director.

The ICC had earlier given Libya until January 10 to confirm whether and when it would surrender Saif al-Islam and to provide information about his health. It extended the deadline until February.


2/10/2012

Why Libya should not join the ICC…Yet

A satirical depiction of an NTC meeting (Cartoon: Pambazuka)

Πηγή: Justice in Conflict
By Mark Kersten
Feb 10 2012

It comes as no surprise that human rights NGOs and those aligned with the International Criminal Court are advocating that Arab Spring states join the ICC. After all, justice and human rights have been central to the uprisings that sprang up last year. One Arab Spring state, Tunisia, already acceded to the Court last June.

In this context, as part of its Universal Ratification Campaign, the Coalition for the International Criminal Court (CICC) recently initiated a targeted effort to get Libya to join the ICC. The CICC, an impressive array of some 2,500 civil society organizations which broadly support the aims of the ICC, released a statement arguing that:

“At a time when sweeping changes are occurring across the Middle East and North Africa (MENA), the Coalition believes that Libya can further strengthen this growing movement in the region towards ending impunity by joining the ICC.”

The Coalition’s Director for Regional Programmes, Brigitte Suhr, noted that joining the court would be in line with hopes for a new human rights respecting Libya:

“Acceding to the Rome Statute would be consistent with the commitment of the government of Libya to uphold human rights as enshrined in its Constitutional Declaration.”

The CICC, along with others urging Libya’s National Transitional Council (NTC) to join the ICC have their work cut out for them. The chances of Libya joining the Court right now are pretty slim. Despite the ongoing question of whether the ICC’s Pre-Trial Chamber will approve of Libya’s plans to try Saif al-Islam Gaddafi and Abdullah al-Senussi in Libya, by Libyans, some, like Chris Stephen, have suggested that the ICC is “the last thing on Tripoli’s mind.”

Members of the NTC (Photo: Action Press)

But just because the Court is not on the NTC’s mind, does not mean that the CICC shouldn’t press on with its aim to put it in the minds of the NTC to sign the Statute. That isn’t the problem. The problem is that demanding that the NTC, an unelected body trying to hold the country together, sign the Rome Statute risks making Libya’s accession to the Court undemocratic.

This is not an attack on the integrity of the NTC or its members. It is expected and legitimate that an unelected transitional authority guide a country from authoritarian rule to democracy, no less after forty years of despotism. Undoubtedly, many of the NTC’s members are doing everything they can to keep the country stable, unified and peaceful despite fragile and precarious circumstances.

That being said, it should be noted that some NTC members have come under sustained attack from citizens for their past allegiances to the Gaddafi regime. Angry at the perceived lack of transparency in the NTC, protesters earlier this year forced the resignation of NTC deputy chief, Abdel Hafiz Ghoga.

Tellingly, an adviser to the interim Prime Minister, Abdel-Rahim el-Keeb, described the NTC as “a government for a crisis…It’s a crisis government. It is impossible to deliver everything.”

As of right now, the NTC’s plan remains to have a general election six months after a Constitution is drafted and approved. It is unclear when that will happen but a general election is supposed to elect a Public National Conference, which will be responsible for drafting a Constitution by June 2012.

While it would be a victory for international criminal justice if Libya became a member of the ICC, it would be a shame if its accession was done without democratic legitimacy.


Some NTC members have been criticized for their past relations and allegiance to Gaddafi

Only once Libya has succeeded in electing a legislature which reflects the diversity of its political landscape should it decide to sign the Rome Statute. Accession to the ICC by a democratic parliament, made up of elected representatives of Libya’s tribal regions and burgeoning political parties, would lend the accession much more legitimacy.

Importantly, when it comes to the ICC’s role, or potential role, in Libya, there is no need to rush. Even if Libya does not sign the Rome Statute, the ICC can continue to investigate. With Resolution 1970, the country remains under the jurisdiction of the ICC indefinitely as there is no temporal jurisdictional limit that constrains the ICC from investigating crimes committed either during the uprising, now or in the future, so long as Libyan authorities demonstrate an inability or unwillingness to do it themselves. In short, for all intents and purposes, the ICC can consider Libya akin to a member state.

Advocates of the ICC, and human rights more broadly, often claim that international criminal justice and democracy are mutually reinforcing. But they shouldn’t pick and choose when to take that link seriously. Libya should become a member of the ICC. But it shouldn’t happen just yet.


2/06/2012

Libya's Saif Gadhafi could be tried within weeks, official says

Abdelali: Gadhafi son will face trial

Πηγή: joyonline
By CNN
Feb 6 2012

Saif al-Islam Gadhafi, the son of Libya's deposed leader Moammar Gadhafi, could go on trial "within weeks or months," the country's interior minister said Sunday.

The investigations into the death of Moammar Gadhafi after his capture last year could also be completed soon, Fawzy Abdilal said.

Saif al-Islam's case will be handed to the courts as soon as the prosecutor general completes his investigations, Abdilal told CNN in an exclusive interview.

Separately, military trials of those who "committed criminal acts under the Gadhafi regime" began Sunday in the city of Benghazi, National Transitional Council member Mohammed El Sayah said.

He did not name those who were being tried, but said "even civilians who had guns and fought under the Gadhafi regime" would be tried before military courts.

Trials elsewhere in the country will start later, he said. Benghazi was the center of resistance to the Gadhafi regime last year.

Saif al-Islam Gadhafi, once his father's heir apparent, was captured in November and has been held in the Libyan city of Zintan since then.

Human Rights Watch said after visiting Saif al-Islam in custody last year that he should have a lawyer, but Abdilal implied he had not asked for one.

"He may have a lawyer if he asks for a lawyer," the interior minister said. "Should Saif demand a lawyer, then a lawyer would be provided."

He also brushed aside accusations that authorities are torturing detainees under the new government.

There are "not systematic violations as there were under the Gadhafi regime," he said, even as he conceded that "there may be cases of individuals who take the law into their own hands."

"There is no comparison whatsoever between the situation prevailing under Moammar Gadhafi and the situation now," he said.

Moammar Gadhafi was killed in October, two months after he was deposed by rebel fighters.

Abdilal said the circumstances of his death were complicated.

"It was a battlefield, he was carrying weapons, there were fighters around, no one was controlling those fighters," Abdilal said.

And, he said, "Many people claim that they are the ones who killed Gadhafi, and that is complicating matters."

Abdilal acknowledged that the interim government had not yet succeeded in integrating militias from different cities into a national security force, saying his visit to Britain was partly to seek help with that task.

Fighters from Zintan still control the international airport, he said, adding that he expected them to hand control over to the Ministry of the Interior "within two weeks."


Libya court postpones trial of Gaddafi loyalists

A new Syrian flag flies over the Russian embassy building as a protester climbs up to place a Libyan flag in Tripoli, February 5, 2012.

Πηγή: Reuters
By Mohammed Al Tommy
Feb 6 2012

Libya started and then swiftly postponed court proceedings on Sunday against 41 Libyans accused of helping Muammar Gaddafi crush the popular revolt that ended in his death last year, Libyan news agency LANA said on Sunday.

"The decision (to postpone) was made in the wake of listening to the pleadings of the defence panel that argued that this military court is not a competent entity and called for referring the case to the civil judiciary," LANA said on its website.

The prosecutors at the trial, which is being held at a military base in the eastern city of Benghazi, have accused the 41 men of murder and aiding prisoners to escape.

Intisar al-Agili, a Benghazi representative of the ruling National Transitional Council, told Reuters the trial had been postponed to February 15.

"The delay is based on the requests of the 15-lawyer defence team to review the evidence ... and on the requests of some detainees who want to hire their own lawyers," she said.

Libya is currently at loggerheads with the International Criminal Court (ICC), after militia fighters captured Saif al-Islam, Gaddafi's most prominent son, in November.

Libya says it will try Saif al-Islam at home, where he could face the death penalty. But the global court based in The Hague has said Libya will first have to answer concerns, raised by activists, that Saif al-Islam was being held incommunicado, without access to lawyers, and to provide information about his mental and physical health.

If the war crimes court rules Libya is unwilling or unable to try Saif al-Islam, who is accused of crimes against humanity over the killing of civilian protesters, it says it will take jurisdiction.

Saif al-Islam would rank among the biggest names to go before the ICC if he were transferred to The Hague for trial.


41 in court at first Libya trial of Gaddafi loyalists


Πηγή: Kashmir Times
Feb 6 2012

Libya put 41 loyalists of dead dictator Muammar Gaddafi on trial, in the first legal proceedings launched against members of the former regime which was ousted after a bloody conflict.

The accused, mostly civilians, appeared in a military court in the eastern city of Benghazi, the birthplace of the uprising against Gaddafi which ended on October 20 with his killing in his home town of Sirte. 

Their trial comes as human rights groups have raised concerns over Libya's judicial system and also accused former rebels of 'torturing' Gaddafi loyalists in custody. 

'It is the first trial concerning the February 17 revolution,' judge Colonel Ali Al Hamida said at the start of the proceedings, referring to the day when the anti-Gaddafi conflict erupted last year in Benghazi. 

The 41, all men, are accused of supporting the Gaddafi regime in its attempts to crush the popular revolt, as well as helping prisoners to escape and setting up 'criminal gangs.' 

An AFP correspondent attending the proceedings said the first session of the trial was held under tight security.

The 15-lawyer defence team for the accused contested the proceedings, saying most of the accused are civilians but are being prosecuted in a military court. 

The trial was later adjourned to February 15.The New-York based Human Rights Watch, in its World Report 2012, has raised concerns over Libya's judicial system. 

'Libya's interim government and its international supporters should make it an urgent priority to build a functioning justice system and begin legal reform that protects human rights after Muammar Gaddafi,' the group said in the report. 

HRW and two other human rights groups, Amnesty International and Doctors Without Borders, have also accused former rebels who helped topple Gaddafi's 42-year-old rule of 'torturing' their prisoners, mainly ex-regime loyalists. 

On Friday, HRW noted that a former ambassador to France, Omar Brebesh, died of possible 'torture' in the custody of a militia less than 24 hours after his detention in Tripoli. 

Amnesty International and Doctors without Borders have also charged that the militias use 'widespread torture' against their prisoners in cities such as Tripoli, Misrata and smaller towns like Ghariyan.

Doctors Without Borders even suspended its work in Misrata over allegations of torture in prisons there.

Libyan officials insist that the country's judiciary is 'competent' to handle the legal cases of former regime members, including putting on trial Gaddafi's most prominent son, Seif Al Islam. Seif, 39, who was arrested on November 19, is in the custody of the military council of Zintan, a town 180 kilometres (110 miles), southwest of Tripoli. 

He is wanted by the International Criminal Court on charges of crimes against humanity allegedly committed during the conflict.


2/02/2012

ICC rejects Gaddafi daughter's appeal on jailed brother


Πηγή: Reuters
By Ivana Sekularac
Feb 2 2012

AMSTERDAM (Reuters) - The International Criminal Court (ICC) said on Thursday it had rejected a request by former Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi's daughter to submit information in the case of her brother, who is awaiting trial in Libya on rape and murder charges.

Saif al-Islam Gaddafi, who was captured disguised as a Bedouin in the Sahara desert in November, has also been indicted by the ICC on charges of crimes against humanity stemming from Libya's civil war last year.

On Tuesday, Aisha Gaddafi had asked the court if she could give information about attempts she has made to contact Saif al-Islam, and submitted a document suggesting the Libyan authorities were unwilling to let any foreign lawyer act for him.

The court said on Thursday that it had rejected both Aisha's request and a similar one by human rights activist Mishana Hosseinioun. Both requests were "misplaced and contrary" to court procedures, a panel of judges said ruled.

Libya's ruling National Transitional Council says Saif al-Islam should be tried at home and would be given a fair hearing. The ICC has reserved the right to insist that he be sent to The Hague.

Saif al-Islam's supporters say they doubt he will be given a fair trial in Libya and that he should be tried instead by the ICC in The Hague.

He faces the death penalty if found guilty by a Libyan court, but only a prison term if convicted by the ICC.

The ICC has jurisdiction over the case because it issued a warrant last year for the arrest of Muammar Gaddafi, Saif al-Islam, and the Libyan leader's intelligence chief, Abdullah al-Senussi.


2/01/2012

Libya: Aisha Gadhafi offers information to help protect brother Saif


Πηγή: CNN
Jan 31 2012

Aisha Gadhafi, the daughter of Libya's deposed strongman Moammar Gadhafi, asked the International Criminal Court Tuesday to accept "concrete information" she believes may help her brother.

Saif al-Islam Gadhafi, once seen as his father's heir apparent, was captured in November after the fall of the regime in August and is being held in the Libyan city of Zintan.

He was facing an arrest warrant from the ICC for alleged crimes against humanity at the time of his capture, and the court, based at The Hague, in the Netherlands, is still seeking to prosecute him.

Conflicting reports emerged a week ago about whether he would be taken to a court in Tripoli to face trial, and the ICC said it had not yet decided if he could be tried in Libya.

The application filed with the ICC by lawyers acting for Aisha Gadhafi says she "wishes to protect the interests of her brother ... whose exact whereabouts are presently unknown to her and whose fate is currently the subject of confidential litigation."

She wishes "to present concrete information which she believes will assist the pretrial chamber in determining the appropriate course of action it should take," the application says.

The "specific" information she holds will "assist the pretrial chamber in determining whether the Libyan authorities truly desire to provide Saif al-Islam Gaddafi with effective legal representation or to afford him a fair trial," the document states.

Aisha Gadhafi's information is based on her attempts to contact her brother through Libyan prosecutors and the International Committee of the Red Cross, in order to find out about his welfare and assign him a lawyer, the appeal says.

She also held two telephone conversations with the deputy prosecutor of Libya, from which it can be inferred that the Libyan authorities "refuse to deal with international legal counsel," it adds.

The ICC initially demanded that Libya hand over Gadhafi for trial after his capture, but then opened the possibility that he could be tried in Libya.

ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno-Ocampo said on a visit to Tripoli that Libya had the "right" to try him if it could prove it could do so fairly, with ICC judges to decide.

The ICC asked Libya last month whether Gadhafi was arrested because of the international warrant, if he was being held incommunicado, and if an ICC representative could meet him.

It also asked when and where a court-appointed expert could examine his physical and mental health, and whether and when they planned to hand him over to the court, giving Libya until January 23 to respond.

Libyan officials have submitted a confidential response to those questions, the ICC said in a statement last week.

In August, as her father's regime crumbled, Aisha Gadhafi fled to Algeria along with several other family members.

She is a onetime U.N. goodwill ambassador, as well as a lawyer who assisted in the defense of deposed Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein, who was hanged in 2006.

Another brother, Saadi Gadhafi, has been granted asylum in Niger.

A third brother, Khamis Gadhafi, who led an army brigade blamed for the massacre of prisoners in a warehouse outside Tripoli, was killed in a late-August battle in northwestern Libya, rebel commanders said. A fourth brother, Saif al-Arab, was reported killed in a NATO airstrike in April.

Moammar Gadhafi himself died after his capture by anti-regime forces near Sirte in October.


1/23/2012

ICC denies deal for Gathafi son to be tried in Libya

Seif is accused of crimes against humanity

Πηγή: Middle East Online
Jan 23 2012

International Criminal Court denies it has agreed Seif al-Islam, Gathafi's most prominent son, can be tried in Libya.

THE HAGUE - The International Criminal Court denied Monday that it had agreed that Seif al-Islam, slain Libyan leader Moamer Gathafi's most prominent son, can be tried in Libya.

"The ICC has made no decision on this matter," court spokesman Fadi el-Abdallah said in response to a claim by Libya's Justice Minister Ali H'mida Ashur that Seif would be judged by a Libyan court.

The ICC said earlier in a Twitter message that it had received a reply from the Libyan authorities to questions asked by its judges by a Monday deadline.

"The ICC has accepted that Seif al-Islam will be tried in Libya by the Libyan judiciary," Ashur said.

"The trial will take place in Libya. The Libyan justice is competent and we gave the file (on Seif) to the ICC on Friday," Ashur added.

Seif, 39, who was arrested on November 19, is in the custody of the military council of Zintan, a town 180 kilometres (110 miles), southwest of Tripoli.

He is wanted by the ICC on charges of crimes against humanity allegedly committed during the conflict in Libya.

Libya's National Transitional Council had already told the ICC in a letter published on November 24 that Tripoli wanted to try him.

The international court had asked Tripoli in December to say by January 6 "if and when" Seif would be handed over for trial in The Hague. That deadline was extended to January 23 at Libya's request because of the "security situation" in the country since the fall of Gathafi in October.

The judges also wanted to know if Seif had been arrested on the ICC warrant issued in June and if it was correct that he was being held incommunicado.

Human Rights Watch said on December 21 after visiting Seif in Zintan that he appeared to be held in good conditions but called on the Libyan authorities to grant him access to a lawyer.

The New-York based Human Rights Watch, in its World Report 2012, has raised concerns over Libya's judicial system.

"Libya’s interim government and its international supporters should make it an urgent priority to build a functioning justice system and begin legal reform that protects human rights after Moamer Gathafi," the group said in the report.

Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East and North Africa director at Human Rights Watch said in the report that "independent courts and the rule of law will help ensure stability in a country emerging from four decades of dictatorship and eight months of war."


1/10/2012

Libya wants more time to update ICC on Gathafi's son

Will Libyans renounce desire for revenge?

Πηγή: Middle East Online
Jan 10 2012

THE HAGUE - Libya has asked for three more weeks to mull the possible handing over of ousted leader Moamer Gathafi's son Seif al-Islam, after a deadline to inform the International Criminal Court expired on Tuesday.

The ICC Registry said it received a letter Monday in which Libyan authorities asked "for an extension of the time limit to submit their observations regarding the arrest of Seif al-Islam".

"Due to the security situation on Libya, the Libyan authorities are not able to meet the deadline and respectfully request the chambers to grant an extension for an additional period of three weeks," the letter said.

The court's judges on December 6 called on Libya's new leaders to inform them as a matter of urgency if and when they intend to hand over Seif and set a January 10 deadline for a response.

"It is up to the chamber to rule on the Libyan authorities' request (for a delay)," ICC spokesman Fadi El-Abdallah said.

The ICC issued a warrant in June for Seif on charges of crimes against humanity over the conflict in Libya, but after his capture the National Transitional Council said it wanted to try him on Libyan soil.

Seif, 39, who was arrested on November 19 -- almost a month to the day after his father was captured and killed -- is now in the custody of the military council of Zintan 180 kilometres (110 miles) southwest of Tripoli.

Human rights organisations have called on the Libyan authorities to grant him access to a lawyer, but said he appeared to be held in good conditions.


12/31/2011

Libya 'broke international justice standards by holding Saif Gaddafi without access to lawyer'


Πηγή: newKerala
By ANI
Dec 31 2011

Tripoli, Dec 31 : The new Libyan government has broken international standards of justice by holding slain dictator Muammar Gaddafi’s son Saif al-Islam without access to a lawyer on charges that could carry the death penalty, a human rights activist has said.


Gaddafi, who was captured on November 19, has been indicted by the International Criminal Court in The Hague on two counts of alleged crimes against humanity.

Libya’s new authorities want to conduct Gaddafi''s trial themselves, possibly including extra charges of alleged corruption. 

But first, they will have to show the ICC that any proceedings would be held under international standards, The Telegraph reports.

Fred Abrahams, a Human Rights Watch researcher who met Saif in detention, said the Libyan authorities’ failure to give him a lawyer fell below these standards. 

“Their unwillingness or inability to grant Saif Gaddafi a lawyer suggests a fair trial is not on the cards,” he added.

Both Libyan and international standards require “prompt” access to a lawyer for a suspect in detention. This means a delay of no more than 48 hours. 

Gaddafi, however, has spent almost six weeks in detention in the town of Zintan.